NEW YORK (
) -- A Georgia doctor says he lost about $23,500 after potentially misleading information on online brokerage
site led him to buy nearly worthless shares of
R.L. Davis, a 49-year-old doctor in Commerce, Ga., says he wanted "to play the stock market and to stick with reputable, established companies (and) that's what I thought I was doing" after reading the description of Motors Liquidation on the online brokerage firm's site.
In fact, the company is a bankruptcy court entity that holds assets and liabilities that the new
did not want.
Under the heading "MTLQQ company overview" the E*Trade site says that Motors Liquidation "is engaged primarily in the development, production and marketing of cars, trucks and parts. It develops, manufactures and markets vehicles worldwide (while its) finance and automotive operations are primarily conducted through GMAC LLC which provides a range of financial services, including consumer vehicle financing, automotive dealership" and other businesses.
The last sentence of the 136-word section notes that substantially all of GM's assets were sold to new GM in bankruptcy court in July, but the relationship between Motos Liquidation and the sale of GM assets is not completely clear from the sentence.
Virtually the same overview or profile, which is a feed from
, is posted on the sites of E*Trade competitors
, along with similar news stories about new GM as well as
and the auto industry.
As a repository for assets and liabilities that remain to be liquidated in bankruptcy, Motors Liquidation has virtually no relationship with new GM, which emerged from bankruptcy on July 10.
As part of the bankruptcy process, shares of Motors Liquidation continue to trade, and may rise and fall, until they are wiped out when the liquidation is completed. That will leave shareholders with zero.
The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, the
Securities and Exchange Commission
and GM all have issued warnings about the nearly worthless shares, but some traders continue to buy and sell them. Additionally, Finra has said it is reviewing trading activity in the stock, and sources have told
that the SEC is also reviewing the trading activity.
Davis says he paid $87,010 for 158,299 shares for Motos Liquidation, purchasing shares on July 21 and July 22 for between 47.5 cents and 52 cents apiece. He sold all of his shares on July 28, after reading on
that the SEC is looking into trading of the worthless shares. After selling his shares for about 40 cents each, he walked away with $63,355. The shares closed Friday at 50 cents, virtually unchanged.
"I found this thing when I entered GM into the computer," Davis says. "E*Trade posted positive things about GM, which made you think it was GM. I think this is misleading." He said he did not see any warnings on the site.
E*Trade spokeswoman Pam Erickson says the company's site provides a variety of information that ought to make it clear to investors that trading in Motors Liquidation is risky, including the last sentence of the overview. "Most investors would clearly understand that a company that has been directed to sell all its assets would be a very high risk investment," she says.
Erickson says a story about the Finra/SEC warning was posted on the E*Trade site; a link to GM's site from the E*Trade site provides multiple alerts to investors about the value of the shares, and a wide variety of recent media and analyst reports, as well as multiple statements by GM, have made it clear the shares are virtually worthless. The E*Trade site also linked to the Finra/SEC release, warning investors about the shares, in mid-July.
She says investors with self-directed brokerage accounts should understand that they are responsible for their investment decisions.
Scottrade spokeswoman Kelly Doria says that Motors Liquidation "is not worthless -- it is still trading at around 50 cents a share" and that "many people are still trading MTLQQ." More than nine million shares traded Friday. Doriasays the final sentence in the boilerplate description makes it clear the company is in bankruptcy. A spokeswoman for Ameritrade could not be reached for comment.
Davis says he started investing several months ago, and did well at first. Told that a lot of people view doctors as lousy investors, he responded, "I think you're right."
-- Written by Ted Reed in Charlotte, N.C.