NEW YORK (
shares have left those of
but it may be time for investors to rethink things.
Wells Fargo has outperformed JPMorgan, not to mention
Bank of America
because it is perceived as having less exposure to Europe and is less dependent on investment banking.
As a result, shares of Wells are down about 16% over the past 100 days, versus more than 28% for JPMorgan, 33% for Goldman, 42% for Citigroup and 51% for Bank of America.
There is no question investment banking revenues have been weak. A
projects investment banking revenues will drop by more than 35% from the fourth quarter of 2010 to the fourth quarter of 2012.
Still, the debate about whether the drop off in investment banking revenues is cyclical or secular is a long way from resolved. Atlantic Equities analyst Richard Staite argues the weak environment will end up benefitting JPMorgan. He notes global competitors like
have been shedding staff and reducing capital deployed in investment banking divisions. He also believes investors are paying increasing attention to counterparty risk and may shift trading to the safest banks such as JPMorgan.
"It is an environment where the strongest banks will get stronger.
JPMorgan gained shared during the US financial crisis and we believe this will continue through the Euro crisis," Staite writes.
What's more, investors typically assign a lower multiple to investment banking revenues than they do to retail banking because they see them as less predictable. But if tighter regulations mean that JPMorgan's revenues investment banking revenues increasingly come from market dominance (winning M&A advisory mandates) rather than risk taking (proprietary trading), investors should be willing to pay a higher multiple.
Then there is leadership to think about. Much has been made of how reliant JPMorgan appears to be on Jamie Dimon, but at 55, Dimon is still relatively young for a CEO. What if he decides to stay put for another 10 years? Meanwhile, Wells Fargo boss John Stumpf, who had the charismatic banking veteran Dick Kovacevich as his Chairman to guide him through the crisis, has to convincingly prove he has a vision for Wells Fargo to take it to through the next decade.
For example, though Wells Fargo is
not without global aspirations
, it is clearly nowhere near JPMorgan in terms of its ability to capture business outside the U.S.
What more, investors have expressed some concerns about weaker margins at Wells Fargo. Pointing to a $137 million decrease in net interest income in the third quarter Stifel Nicolaus stated in a recent report that "here is clearly core margin compression that is occurring."
Stifel's analysts believe this trend will reverse itself, and retain their "buy" rating on the stock. Still, the upside on JPMorgan would appear to be far greater, and the downside appears overstated.
Written by Dan Freed in New York
Disclosure: TheStreet's editorial policy prohibits staff editors, reporters and analysts from holding positions in any individual stocks.