Skip to main content

A look at recent performance in the airline sector offers a starting point for finding potential winners -- and losers -- in the industry. We're talking short-term buying here. No long-term discussions are allowed -- not even medium-term. Let's just focus on quick get-'em-and-hit-'em stocks.

In the following chart, the first column shows how the stock fared for the third quarter before Sept. 11. The second column indicates its performance for the balance of the quarter after Sept. 11, and the third shows what the stock has done for the past seven trading days.

On the Radar

Right now I like


(CAL) - Get Caleres, Inc. Report

, only because it has the most bounce potential. Its stock dropped more than any other major airline after the hijacking tragedies. However, it has rebounded only 19% in the past seven days. The airline said Tuesday that it has about $1.2 billion in cash, so I don't think bankruptcy is on the immediate horizon.

US Airways


is another good one. It dropped 60% immediately after Sept. 11, but bounced up only 13%. A good portion of that bounce came Tuesday, after the feds announced the reopening of Reagan National Airport near Washington, D.C. However, US Airways is a potential bankruptcy candidate, so be wary.

Caution Ahead

Atlantic Coast


may have done most of its bouncing already. It jumped 39% over the past seven days because

United Airlines

, its code-share partner, is giving Atlantic Coast additional routes to fly -- most of which used to be mainline United routes.

Caution is also needed with


TheStreet Recommends

(MESA) - Get Mesa Air Group Inc Report

, which counts both

America West


and US Airways as partners. To put it bluntly, I don't know how America West will avoid bankruptcy, and US Airways has its own problems, too. Because of these issues, Mesa's stock took a huge hit when trading resumed Sept. 17. For the period after Sept. 11, the stock was down 78%.

However, the stock surged 35% Tuesday on news that it would start flying some former mainline routes for America West. But even with this sizable leap, the stock is up only 2% over the past seven days. That's very volatile property, and it could give you a big hit up or down.

Just like Atlantic Coast,


(SKYW) - Get SkyWest, Inc Report

has bounced very hard in the past seven trading days. How much more is left in the shorter term?


(WJA:Toronto) and


(RYAAY) - Get Ryanair Holdings Plc Sponsored ADR Report

, both clones of

Southwest Airlines

(LUV) - Get Southwest Airlines Co. Report

, have held up extremely well. I love them for the long term, but other stocks may see a better bounce in the short term. The same goes for Southwest.

Stocks to Avoid

Air Canada


and America West are both bankruptcy candidates.



attempt to go private is now dead, as financing was pulled. I wouldn't play with this one, and the float is too small.

I've got some cash questions about

Northwest Airlines


. I'll be interested in the traffic numbers it reports for September.



? It's just a no-growth airline.

Mystery Stock

For an airline that wasn't doing well financially before Sept. 11,

Midwest Express


has seen an explosive increase in volume over the past few days. Its stock is up 23% over the past seven days and was still moving Wednesday. Something's going on here.

Outside the Immediate Sector

I've also noted recent performance of some airline-related stocks, such as online travel services and aircraft manufacturers.

Look how well the travel-related stocks have done.



has done


well, as a matter of fact. Is there more bounce left? Could be. Remember that priceline tends to be a volatile property in the best of times.

Aircraft manufacturers? I'd forget them. Nobody is looking to buy new planes anytime soon.

Holly Hegeman pilots the Wing Tips column. At time of publication, Hegeman held no positions in any securities mentioned in this column, although holdings can change at any time. Under no circumstances does the information in this column represent a recommendation to buy or sell stocks. You can usually find Hegeman, publisher of PlaneBusiness Banter, buzzing around her airline industry Web site at While she cannot provide investment advice or recommendations, she welcomes your feedback and invites you to send it to

Holly Hegeman.