Skip to main content



) -- Hurricane Earl is not only threatening Labor Day plans, it could also threaten some insurers balance sheets.

"It really depends on exactly where it lands and their market share. It is almost impossible to tell how much the losses will be yet," says Paul Newsome, managing director and the senior insurance analyst at Sandler O'Neill & Partners. "It's probably not going to be a significant insurance event, but you never know."

As the Category 4 storm makes its way through the Caribbean, forecasters and insurance companies are looking at which part of the US East Coast the storm might hit and are preparing for the catastrophic losses.

Boston-based catastrophe modeling firm AIR Worldwide estimates that losses could be as high as $33 billion based on "a repeat of the 1938 Great New England Hurricane," AIR spokesman Kevin Long says. "Not that Earl is following the same track as the 1938

storm... This is just to put things in perspective in terms of insured loss potential."

Michael Nannizzi, executive director of equity research at Oppenheimer, says that


(CB) - Get Chubb Limited Report

has the greatest exposure to losses if the hurricane hits the east coast directly. Two other companies that face exposures to the hurricane are


(ALL) - Get Allstate Corporation (The) Report

, and


Scroll to Continue

TheStreet Recommends

(TRV) - Get The Travelers Companies Inc. Report


"If you look at all of the East Coast from the Carolinas northward to Maine, Chubb owns about 9% of the market and Travelers and Allstate own 6% of the market share," Nannizzi added.

"We continue to like Chubb because of this hurricane. What Chubb is really good at is handling claims and most people that file claims will stick with Chubb for life. Chubb is still at the top of its game. This is an opportunity for them to differentiate themselves," Nannizzi said.

Newsome says that other property and casualty companies facing exposure will include




Cincinnati Financial Corporation

(CINF) - Get Cincinnati Financial Corporation Report


The Hartford

(HIG) - Get Hartford Financial Services Group Inc. (The) Report

and to a lesser extent


(PGR) - Get Progressive Corporation (The) Report


"ACE Ltd also writes reinsurance, increasing its exposure to catastrophe losses from hurricanes. Assuming $9 billion of industry-wide losses, we estimate that the companies we cover would incur moderate losses. These estimates exclude the effects of reinsurance," Newsome wrote in a note.

--Written by Maria Woehr in New York.

To contact the writer of this article, click here:

Maria Woehr


To follow the writer on Twitter, go to


>To submit a news tip, send an email to: