Skip to main content

Apple's (AAPL) - Get Apple Inc. Report royalty dispute with Qualcomm (QCOM) - Get Qualcomm Inc Report has been a distraction from the 10th anniversary edition of the iPhone due out later this year.

Qualcomm ratcheted up the litigation this week when it filed suit against Apple contract manufacturers Foxconn, Pegatron, Wistron, and Compal, for skipping royalty payments. The chipmaker said in April that Apple is withholding payments to its contract manufacturers to cover the royalties they owe Qualcomm. Moreover, Qualcomm alleges that Apple ordered the companies to withhold the funds, and has indemnified them.

Messy as the fight with Qualcomm has become, Wells Fargo (WFC) - Get Wells Fargo & Company Report analyst Maynard Um suggests that Apple's dispute with Nokia (NOK) - Get Nokia Oyj Report is a bigger near-term concern. Nokia filed suit in two German venues, a U.S. District Court in Texas and other venues in December, alleging patent violations.

"While most of the focus has been on [Qualcomm] given the recent headlines, we believe the Nokia litigation is more important with the potential for initial news flow as early as the end of calendar 2017," Um wrote.

Nokia has filed complaints in Munich and Mannheim, Germany that could have rulings this year this year. Other disputes, such as a complaint in the Netherlands, could reach outcomes soon after.

TheStreet Recommends

Um estimates that Nokia previously received just 0.2% of the price of the device in which Apple uses its technology. Nokia is unlikely to score the 2.7% rate that Qualcomm receives, Um suggested. If Nokia could obtain a 1.5% rate, it could reduce Apple's earnings per share by 20 cents.

Qualcomm could also set Apple earnings back by 20 cents per share if Apple has to pay the 2.7% royalty. Um did not propose a timeline for the conclusion of the lawsuits with Qualcomm, but suggested that the Nokia case would likely have an outcome sooner.

Shares of Apple gained 1.5% to $152.54 on Thursday and was up 0.6% in early trading Friday, after losing nearly 3.5% in Wednesday's broad selloff. Jim Cramer suggested on Real Money that Apple and other tech stalwarts have strong enough prospects to withstand band news from Washington.

Apple is a holding in Jim Cramer's Action Alerts PLUS Charitable Trust Portfolio. Want to be alerted before Cramer buys or sells AAPL? Learn more now.

Expectations for a banner iPhone sales may help investors see opportunity beyond the political turmoil, but Um suggested that they should not look past Apple's patent disputes.

"While, understandably, the key investor focus continues to be on the upcoming iPhone 8 cycle, we believe these legal disputes have the risk of introducing volatility to [Apple]'s share price if/when initial rulings are made," Um wrote.