Norfolk Southern -- Buy Before the Revisions
BOSTON (TheStreet) -- Buy before the train leaves the station.
That's the opinion of
Barclays
(BCS) - Get Barclays Plc Report
analysts. The bank's Gary Chase said more cargo and higher prices will serve as catalysts for railroad companies in the first quarter of 2010, causing analysts to revise their earnings estimates on better-than-expected results, to be released this month.
Barclays' favorite pick is Virginia-based
Norfolk Southern
(NSC) - Get Norfolk Southern Corporation Report
, whose stock gained 11% last month. Norfolk Southern is scheduled to release its financial report on April 27.
Fourth-quarter profit tumbled 32% to $307 million, or 82 cents a share, as revenue fell 16% to $2.1 billion. The operating margin narrowed from 32% to 26%, tighter than those of competitors
Canadian National Railway
(CNI) - Get Canadian National Railway Company Report
and
Union Pacific
(UNP) - Get Union Pacific Corporation Report
. Norfolk's return on equity of 10% also lagged behind peers'.
TheStreet Recommends
Barclays expects the stock to rise because "longer-term expectations are lowest."
TheStreet's
stock model measures Norfolk's PEG ratio, a measure of value relative to expected growth, at 1, indicating it's fairly valued. (A PEG ratio below 1 would signify a bargain.) But if Barclays is correct and analysts are overly pessimistic about the company's growth prospects, the stock may get a lift as forecasts rise.
Based on traditional valuation measures, Norfolk Southern is cheaper than its peer group. The stock trades at a price-to-projected-earnings ratio of 14, a price-to-book ratio of 2 and a price-to-cash-flow ratio of 11, reflecting 28%, 17% and 4.6% discounts to its respective industry averages.
TheStreet's
model rates Norfolk Southern "hold," ranking it as the 10th-best rail stock, behind "buy"-rated Canadian National, Union Pacific and
CSX Corp.
(CSX) - Get CSX Corporation Report
.
However, Barclays isn't the only firm advising clients to purchase shares. Of researchers covering Norfolk Southern, 14, or 56%, rate its stock "buy" and 11 rate it "hold."
Stifel Nicolaus
(SF) - Get Stifel Financial Corp. Report
and
Deutsche Bank
(DB) - Get Deutsche Bank AG Report
expect Norfolk Southern to advance 11% to $64.
Credit Suisse
(CS) - Get Credit Suisse Group AG Report
expects the shares to touch $63 and
UBS
(UBS) - Get UBS Group AG Report
agrees with Barclays, projecting a share price of $62. Despite limited upside, the stock deserves consideration.
Norfolk Southern's stock has returned 4% annually, since 2007, excluding dividends. Barclays' thesis could prove accurate, but in the latest reporting period, Norfolk Southern missed consensus estimates by a margin of 2.5% for adjusted earnings per share and 2.7% for GAAP EPS. The stock dropped 4.6% upon announcement. Eight of the 10 largest shareholders, including
State Street
(STT) - Get State Street Corporation Report
and
BlackRock
(BLK) - Get BlackRock, Inc. Report
, enlarged their bets in the fourth quarter.
-- Reported by Jake Lynch in Boston.
