Skip to main content

How Many Big Electric Bills Does It Take to Change a Light Bulb?

Switching to environmentally friendly light bulbs can chop down your electric bill.
  • Author:
  • Publish date:

To conserve both energy costs and the environment from within your home, seek higher inspiration.

That is, look at your ceilings and contemplate the light bulbs screwed into the fixtures.


Department of Energy estimates that the average household spends 11% of its energy budget on lighting. But if you're willing to trade in the incandescent bulbs that Thomas Edison developed in 1880 for newer innovations, you can knock those costs down by as much as 75%, enough to make a noticeable difference on your electric bill.

The most common replacements for conventional bulbs are compact fluorescents. Yes, they were once known for poor lighting and u-shaped designs that didn't actually fit in most fixtures. But

General Electric

(GE) - Get General Electric Company Report


Philips Electronics

(PHG) - Get Koninklijke Philips N.V. NY Registry Shares Report



(SI) - Get Silvergate Capital Corporation Class A Report

, among others, now make them in a range of sizes and shapes that are easily interchangeable with conventional light bulbs in lamps and ceiling fixtures.

Compact fluorescents aren't catching on as quickly as environmental advocates would like, primarily because of the upfront price tag. You can by a two-pack of standard GE 60-watt bulbs at


Scroll to Continue

TheStreet Recommends

(LOW) - Get Lowe's Companies Inc. Report

for $1.98. Compact fluorescents can cost two or three times as much, at least.

But it's not an apples-to-apples comparison. A 15-watt compact fluorescent will provide as much light as a 60-watt incandescent, which means the newer bulb uses a quarter of the power to get the same amount of light -- that's a 75% savings every time you flip the light switch.

Additionally, that compact fluorescent will provide 10,000 hours of light, while the conventional bulb will provide 1,000 to 1,500 hours. That means you have to buy six to 10 of Edison's old bulbs for every one energy efficient bulb you buy.

Put another way, you're spending $6 to $10 on incandescents for every $2 or $3 you would spend on the CFBs.

One billion bulbs does a good job of showing how the costs add up.

For an assessment of your own home, Environmental Defense has a

calculator that shows how much money and carbon dioxide you'll save by replacing your incandescent bulbs. Assuming I had

conventionally sourced electricity, which is typically generated using a lot of fossil fuel, if I replace just four 60-watt bulbs with 15-watt energy-efficient ones, I can save about $500 over the life of those new bulbs and spare the atmosphere some 1,650 pounds of CO2.

Detractors of the compact fluorescent like to point out that there's mercury in them, which doesn't seem very green.

Treehugger observes that each bulb contains less mercury than is generated by waste from the power plant firing up your incandescents. But the mercury often makes it illegal to throw the lamps in the regular trash and can cause a toxic mess, albeit a tiny one, if they break in your house. They usually can't be tossed in with the rest of your recycling either.


Lighterfootstep blog argues that this is a smaller problem than it might seem when you remember that you only have to throw these bulbs out every few years, but it still poses a quandary. If these bulbs are going to become household mainstays, public sanitation departments will have to find a way to deal with them.

In the meantime,

Ikea recycles the light bulbs it sells, and the

EPA provides information about recycling programs nationwide. The agency also provides information on what to do if you

break a bulb -- a situation that requires caution but not panic.

Energy Star has an information sheet you can download if you need more information on getting rid of your bulbs.

A more immediate issue exists on the buying end: If you try to switch in these bulbs throughout your home you'll quickly find they still don't easily work everywhere. CFBs that are small and decorative enough to use in a chandelier are hard to come by and pricey -- costing $7 to $12 apiece at one

online lighting store. They also don't play well with dimmers.

Environmental Defense explains

why, if you can find dimmable CFBs at all, they won't have the same light range as an incandescent. And they'll also be expensive. Even


(WMT) - Get Walmart Inc. Report

, which has been heavily

promoting energy efficient bulbs, carries only one dimmable CFB in its

online store, and that one costs $12. At an eco-friendly specialty store they can

cost as much as $20 apiece.

Despite these drawbacks, Americans who aren't naturally inclined to buy into the money saving and green advantages of newer bulbs may be given a big nudge from Congress. Two

Senators have introduced legislation that would compel light bulb makers to start phasing out conventional 40-, 60-, 75- and 100-watt incandescents in favor of halogen, compact fluorescent and more efficient incandescent bulbs starting in 2012. The bipartisan bill was developed with cooperation from both major light-bulb makers and environmental groups such as the

Natural Resources Defense Council.

Bright idea or not, with that kind of cooperation behind it, the legislation probably has legs.

Why not get out in front of it and save some money and a few carbon emissions without that push from Washington.

Eileen P. Gunn writes about the business of life and is the author of "Your Career Is An Extreme Sport." You can learn more about her at

her Web site.