Morningstar Conference: Barclays' Dunn Throws Down the Gauntlet
CHICAGO --
Morningstar
was brave enough to offer the keynote address at its annual investment conference to the chairman of the company that poses the biggest threat to the mutual fund industry.
And
Barclays Global Investors
Chairman Patricia Dunn, did nothing to put the industry at ease, attacking mutual funds as costly and inefficient and dismissing low-cost fund leader
Vanguard
as yesterday's news.
Barclays has launched more than two dozen exchange-traded funds, or ETFs, which are essentially mutual funds that are continually priced and traded on a stock exchange. Many believe ETFs, which have attracted some $45 billion so far, are a potent threat to both actively and passively managed mutual funds because they combine the convenience of stock-like trading with potentially higher tax efficiency and lower costs than traditional funds.
Dunn's first target: actively managed mutual funds that, she said, shun price comparisons by cloaking portfolios and their management process in secrecy, rarely explaining what investors get for their money and making pragmatic comparison shopping arduous.
"Our industry has an enormous vested interest in the mystique of investment management," she says, noting that some $130 billion was taken from investors' portfolios in the form of management fees and other expenses last year.
Too often, she says, investors who own actively managed funds "pay Picasso prices for paint-by-the-numbers work."
Sounding a lot like Vanguard's former chairman Jack Bogle, she trumpeted index funds as the best choice for an investor's core equity investments. "Index funds are like super-securities that allow us to focus on our objectives, rather than the sugar high of owning this year's hot stocks."
Then she promptly attacked Bogle's old shop, Vanguard, and its traditional approach to index investing. She pointed out that exchange-traded funds boast greater convenience and lower annual expenses than traditional index mutual funds.
She noted that shareholders of the
(VFINX) - Get Vanguard Index Trust 500 Index Fund Report
TheStreet Recommends
Vanguard 500 Index fund, which tracks the
S&P 500
index, paid 1.77% of their investments in capital gains over the past three years. Over the same period, she said, an ETF tracking the same index,
Spiders
(SPY) - Get S&P 500 ETF TRUST ETF Report
, left investors with no capital gains tax burdens.
"There's only one organization that built itself on the value-for-money approach and that's Barclays Global Investors," she says, clearly snubbing cost-obsessed Vanguard, which plans to launch ETFs of its own called VIPERs.
What about the drawbacks of ETFs? Namely that their stock-like trading capability could spur excessive trading, a gripe voiced by Bogle at the conference on Wednesday night.
Dunn, while acknowledging that ETFs typically have shorter holding periods than mutual funds, says the numbers are skewed since active traders typically steer clear of traditional mutual funds, which often levy redemption fees for short-term traders.
Managers Find Value in Tech
Tech-fund managers are sounding a lot like value managers these days.
Three who spoke on a Friday panel at the Morningstar Investment Conference say they have been sifting this year's tech wreckage for oversold stocks that have patents, fat market share or some vital edge that could help them trounce current competitors and ward off new entrants.
"The key to investing in technology is finding companies with key competitive advantages. The size of the moat around your castle will define your success," says John Sykora, co-manager of tech-heavy
(TWCUX) - Get American Century Ultra Investor Class Report
American Century Ultra fund.
Which stocks have the deepest moats?
Cathy Baker, co-manager of
(RIAFX)
RS Internet Age, likes
Knight Trading
(NITE)
a leading market maker in
Nasdaq
stocks, meaning it provides the necessary liquidity to keep bid and offer prices from being too wide for trading to occur. The company's acumen and deep traction with online brokers like
E*Trade
should be a big boost, says Baker.
Ryan Jacob of the
(JAMFX) - Get Jacob Internet Fund Investorhares Report
Jacob Internet fund offered wireless data shop
Aether Systems
(AETH)
because it leads competitors in paving the way for mobile online commerce, where he sees big profits down the road.
"It will not only be a big opportunity here in the U.S., but also globally in terms of providing Internet access," he said.
Sykora says he sees
America Online
(AOL)
as a juggernaut. It has 23 million subscribers and grabs one of every two new subscribers, positioning it to rake in fat advertising revenue, which grew by 100% last quarter, he says.
He also likes
Gemstar
(GMST)
, which owns many patents for the technology used in interactive TV guides.
Jacob and Baker both own online media concern
About.com
(BOUT) - Get Innovator IBD(R) Breakout Opportunities ETF Report
, hailing its cost-effective customer acquisition and proximity to profitability.
Despite their excitement about these picks, it's not all blue skies. Lest we forget, many of last year's dot-com darlings have been smacked this year, some dropping 80%. Baker notes that many e-tailers and other unprofitable Net stocks will fold, and Jacob says investors should stay out of Net stocks unless they're prepared for "stomach-churning volatility."
Still, the trio thinks the glass is half-full. When asked if the volatility will continue, Sykora said, "I hope so." He thinks it's clearing a path to attractively priced opportunities.
Miller Gives Tech a Rest
At a panel on value investing, three respected practitioners, Christopher Davis of the
(NYVTX) - Get Davis New York Venture Fund A Report
Davis NY Venture and
(SLASX) - Get Selected American Shares Inc. Report
Selected American funds, Bill Nygren of the
(OAKMX) - Get Oakmark Fund Investor Class Report
Oakmark and
(OAKLX) - Get Oakmark Select Fund Investor Class Report
Oakmark Select funds, and Bill Miller of
(LMVTX) - Get ClearBridge Value Trust Cl C Report
Legg Mason Value Trust and
(LMOPX) - Get Miller Opportunity Trust - CL C Report
Legg Mason Opportunity, presented a united front against critics who doubt the value credentials of managers who invest in technology.
"If you call yourself a value investor, it doesn't mean that you have to say you don't understand technology," says Nygren.
But Miller, famous for his early stakes in
Amazon.com
(AMZN) - Get Amazon.com Inc. Report
and America Online, says he's shying away from technology nowadays, feeling it's overvalued. Instead, he says he has been picking up shares of savings and loan
Washington Mutual
(WM) - Get Waste Management Inc. Report
. He also likes grocers
Kroger
(KR) - Get Kroger Company (The) Report
and
Albertson's
(ABS)
.
The Next Not-Too-Big Thing
Mid-cap stocks have been the sweet spot of the market during the tech shakeout, primarily because mid-caps capture much of the growth momentum of smaller companies with the stability of older businesses with track records.
"You don't get your feathers singed if you're in the middle," notes Colin Ferenbach, skipper of the
(HAVEX)
Haven fund.
But when it comes to which stocks are poised for big run-ups, Ferenbach and others on a panel of mid-cap fund managers could find much to agree on, given their different styles. Doug Foreman, manager of the
(MCFAX) - Get Miller Convertible Bond Fund Report
MSDW Mid-Cap Equity fund, prefers tech names like semiconductor player
Xilinx
(XLNX) - Get Xilinx Inc. Report
and routing systems provider
Juniper Networks
(JNPR) - Get Juniper Networks Inc. Report
.
Tim Miller, who runs
(FIDYX)
Invesco Dynamics, is also fond of tech, but focuses on e-commerce software provider
BroadVision
(BVSN) - Get BroadVision Inc. Report
and tech storage player
Brocade
(BRCD)
.
Ferenbach, who employs a growth-at-a-reasonable price strategy, likes medical-devices company
Medtronic
(MDT) - Get Medtronic plc. Report
, though he thinks it's currently too pricey.
Earlier Morningstar conference stories:
Growth Managers Say Wireless Rings Their Bell
The Fight For Disclosure Rages On
ETFs Take Center Stage
