Buy-Write Funds: The Right Call in Any Market

The funds chug reliably on, with no big losses in downturns and modest returns in bull markets.
Publish date:

NEW YORK (TheStreet) -- In recent years, buy-write funds have outpaced the S&P 500 by wide margins. That's hardly surprising. The funds are designed to excel in markets that are flat or down. "If stocks return less than 4% or so, odds are good that we will outperform," says Donald J. Mulvihill, portfolio manager of Goldman Sachs U.S. Equity Dividend and Premium Fund (GSPAX) - Get Report, which uses buy-write techniques.

The buy-write funds aim to avoid big losses in downturns and crank out modest returns in bull markets. Over the long term, buy-write strategies have about matched the S&P 500 while taking less risk. Because they don't always track the overall stock market, buy-write funds can help diversify portfolios.

The typical buy-write fund purchases stocks and then sells -- or writes -- call options. A call gives an investor the right to buy a stock in the future for a fixed price. A fund might start by buying shares of

International Business Machines

(IBM) - Get Report

, which recently traded around $128. Then to generate extra income, the portfolio manager sells a call that gives the buyer the right to purchase the shares for $130 by this October. The investor pays the fund a premium of $3.81 for the call. Why bother spending the cash? The call enables the investor to control the shares without putting up the full price of the stock.

Selling the call benefits the fund under most scenarios. Say the stock stays flat. The fund keeps its stock and the $3.81 premium, boosting the return on the IBM holdings. If the shares rise to $140, the fund must the sell the stock to the call buyer, who will only pay the fixed price of $130. The fund misses most of the upside appreciation. But no matter what, the fund collects the premium, which eases any disappointments.

Buy-write funds follow a variety of strategies. Some funds only sell calls on part of their portfolios, while other managers sell calls against all their holdings.

Eaton Vance Tax-Managed Buy-Write Income

(ETB) - Get Report

, a closed-end fund, starts with a stock portfolio that roughly tracks the S&P 500. Then the fund sells S&P 500 index calls against the entire portfolio. This plain-vanilla approach has worked well during the downturn. During the past three years, the fund has returned 3.5% annually, outpacing the S&P 500 by 10 percentage points, according to


(MORN) - Get Report


For more downside protection, consider

Eaton Vance Risk-Managed Equity Option Income Fund


, an open-end fund. The fund sells calls on a portfolio that roughly tracks the S&P 500. Then, for an added layer of protection, portfolio manager Walter Row buys put options. Those serve as insurance, appreciating in value when stocks drop. "With the fund, you don't get a lot of upside, but you don't get much downside either," Row says.

While the Eaton Vance fund may never score outsized gains, it can provide a steady source of income. The portfolio collects income from stock dividends and option premiums. Most of the income is distributed to shareholders. The fund currently pays a distribution of 7.7%, a tidy sum at a time when 10-year Treasuries yield 2.63%.

Some funds vary the amount of calls that they use.

Goldman Sachs U.S. Equity Dividend and Premium Fund

(GSPAX) - Get Report

writes calls that cover from 15% to 35% of the portfolio. The fund buys a diversified group of dividend-paying stocks that roughly track the S&P 500. Then manager Donald Mulvihill sells enough index calls to generate premiums equal to 4% of the portfolio. The aim is to pay shareholders distributions of 5% to 6%.

Mulvihill changes his option holdings to meet the income targets. During periods when option premiums are higher, he can sell fewer calls and still meet the income goal. The fund's premium income has helped cushion the portfolio. Thanks to the option premiums, the fund outdid the S&P 500 by 5 percentage points in the downturn of 2008.

Neiman Large Cap Value

(NEIMX) - Get Report

typically writes calls on about one-third of the portfolio's stocks. The fund returned 3.3% annually during the past five years, compared with a loss of 0.2% for the S&P 500. Harvey and Dan Neiman -- a father-and-son team of portfolio managers -- favor industry-leading companies that generate increasing dividends. "We want to collect dividends from low-volatility stocks, and then we enhance the income by selling calls," Harvey Neiman says.

A favorite holding is

Emerson Electric

(EMR) - Get Report

, which produces motors and parts used by manufacturers. The company has a rock-solid balance sheet and a long record for increasing dividends, Dan Neiman says. He also likes

Canadian National Railway

(CNI) - Get Report

, a dominant railroad that should report steadily rising revenues.

Readers Also Like:

>>Real Estate Revival Seen by Fund Managers

Follow on


and become a fan on


Stan Luxenberg is a freelance writer who specializes in mutual funds and investing. He was formerly executive editor of Individual Investor magazine.