Skip to main content

BOSTON (TheStreet) -- The 10 worst-performing mutual funds are finding that what worked in 2009 is failing this year.

Banks and health-care companies led the stock market last year. But investors took on more risk as 2010 wore on, encouraged by a rebound in corporate profits, particularly in technology, and the government's economic-stimulus plans.

The

top performer

among diversified mutual funds that primarily buy large U.S. companies is

Morgan Stanley Focus Growth

(AMOBX)

, which has risen 25% this year through Nov. 29. The benchmark

S&P 500 Index

has climbed 4.8%.

The worst performers have barely eked out gains.

Invesco Basic Value

(GTVLX)

has returned 0.5%, and

Janus Twenty

(JNTFX)

Scroll to Continue

TheStreet Recommends

has increased 2.4%.

None of the managers have taken odd or risky positions. They're facing challenges ranging from new management to bad timing on industry bets. Sticking with these funds may require a leap of faith and a bottle of antacids, as they've yo-yo'd over the past three years, losing as much as 52% in 2008, gaining much of it back the following year, then treading water this year.

It didn't take much of a miscue to end up on this list, as just a few clunkers among the top holdings can lead to overall losses. Several managers expected the economy to charge ahead and invested in mega-cap stocks in financial services and computer hardware. But many have been hamstrung from investments in

Bank of America

(BAC) - Get Bank of America Corporation Report

,

Cisco

(CSCO) - Get Cisco Systems Inc. Report

and

Hewlett-Packard

(HPQ) - Get HP Inc. Report

, each of which are down about 20% this year.

Such is the case for Janus fund manager Ron Sachs, who is having a trying year. Three of his funds are on the list.

A lesson to be learned from these funds' travails is that successful mutual-fund management is as much about limiting losses as maximizing gains.

This article's rankings are based on data provided by Morningstar and includes mutual funds with $1 billion or more in assets that are the worst performers in the large-capitalization growth, value or blend (growth and value) categories, with less than 30% of assets in small- or mid-cap stocks. Industry- and country-specific funds are excluded.

In inverse order, here are the 10 worst-performing funds, their key holdings and strategy:

10.

JANUS TWENTY

(JNTFX)

RETURN

: 2.4%

ASSETS

: $ 9.3 billion

MANAGER

: Ron Sachs, since January 2008

TOP STOCKS

:

Apple

(AAPL) - Get Apple Inc. Report

, 12%,

Celgene

(CELG) - Get Celgene Corporation Report

, 7%, and

Anheuser Busch

(ABI)

, 5.3%

BIG WINNER

:

Tyco Electronics

(TEL) - Get TE Connectivity Ltd. Report

, 2% of fund assets, is up 36% this year.

STRATEGY

: This fund's concentrated portfolio -- 38 stocks with 52% of the fund invested in the top 10 -- worked against it. Its three biggest losers are

Cisco

(CSCO) - Get Cisco Systems Inc. Report

, at 4.7% of the fund, down 20% this year;

Google

(GOOG) - Get Alphabet Inc. Report

, at 4.7%, down 7.6%; and

Bank of America

(BAC) - Get Bank of America Corporation Report

, at 3.5%, down 21%.

The 50% gain of its largest holding,

Apple

(AAPL) - Get Apple Inc. Report

, at 12%, wasn't enough to offset the losers. It had several other winners -- retailer

Limited Brands

(LTD)

, up 73%, and

Ford

(F) - Get Ford Motor Company Report

, up 68%, but they weren't enough to make up the lost ground. The fund lost 42% in 2008 and returned 43% last year. Computer hardware, at 20%, is the largest sector weighting, followed by financial services, at 18%.

9.

PRUDENTIAL JENNISON 20/20 FOCUS

(PTWAX) - Get PGIM Jennison 20/20 Focus A Report

RETURN

: 2.2%

ASSETS

: $2.5 billion

MANAGER

: Sipros Segalas, since 1998; David Kiefer, since 2004

TOP STOCKS

:

Novartis

(NVS) - Get Novartis AG Report

, 4.3%,

Apple

(AAPL) - Get Apple Inc. Report

, 3.7%, and

Bunge

(BG) - Get Bunge Limited Report

, 3.2%

BIG WINNER

:

Liberty Global

(LBTYK) - Get Liberty Global plc Report

, 2.6% of the fund, up 60%.

STRATEGY

: Although the fund holds only 39 stocks, it has a diverse portfolio because most of its top 25 holdings have a roughly 2% allocation. The fund's holdings change once within a calendar year -- the managers are big traders. There were no home runs in the portfolio, but there were a couple of big losers, including

H&R Block

(HRB) - Get H&R Block Inc. Report

, down 40%, and

Southwestern Energy

(SWN) - Get Southwestern Energy Company Report

, down 22%.

Big bets on energy stocks, the largest fund sector at 14%, didn't pay off. The best performer is

Liberty Global

(LBYTK)

, which owns cable satellite networks in Europe, Australia and South America. It has soared 60%.

8.

INVESCO CHARTER

(CHTRX) - Get Invesco Charter A Report

RETURN

: 2.2%

ASSETS

: $ 5.3 billion

MANAGER

: Ronald Sloan, 2002; Brian Nelson and Tyler Dann II, both 2007.

TOP STOCKS

: Cash or equivalents, 20%,

Kroger

(KR) - Get Kroger Company (The) Report

, 3.3%, and

Progressive

(PGR) - Get Progressive Corporation (The) Report

, 3.1%

BIG WINNER

:

Baker Hughes

(BHI)

, 2% of the fund, up 36%.

STRATEGY

: A fifth of the fund is in cash, which means it lost out on late-in-the-year gains. There are no big losers in the portfolio -- the biggest, by far, is

Boston Scientific

(BSX) - Get Boston Scientific Corporation Report

, down 24% -- but there are no big winners, either.

The largest industry weighting is health care, at 17%, and financial services, at 16%. Those two are out of favor with investors after a big run last year.

7.

LEGG MASON CAPITAL MANAGEMENT VALUE

(LMVTX) - Get ClearBridge Value C Report

RETURN

: 2.11%

ASSETS

: $4 billion

MANAGER

: Bill Miller, since 1982; Mary Chris Gay (March 2006), Sam Peters (November 2010)

TOP STOCKS

:

AES

(AES) - Get The AES Corporation Report

, 7.4%,

Transocean

(RIG) - Get Transocean Ltd (Switzerland) Report

, 4%, and

IBM

(IBM) - Get International Business Machines Corporation Report

, 3.8%

BIG WINNER

:

Genzyme

(GENZ)

, 2.7% of the fund, up 44%.

STRATEGY

: This fund's returns are a roller-coaster, losing 55% in 2008, gaining 41% in 2009, and struggling once again this year. When your top two stock picks, which make up 11% of assets, are double-digit losers, you've got challenges.

The biggest holding,

AES

(AES) - Get The AES Corporation Report

, is an electric utility, while

Transocean

(RIG) - Get Transocean Ltd (Switzerland) Report

is a supplier of oil-field services, notably to offshore oil rigs.

The fund holds 43 stocks and the top 10 make up 38% of the portfolio. Turnover is a tiny 3.9%. Financial services is the top sector weighting, at 25%, followed by computer hardware, at 16%, and health care, at 16% -- two out-of-favor sectors. Biotechnology giant

Genzyme

leads the gainers.

6.

EATON VANCE DIVIDEND BUILDER

(EVTMX) - Get Eaton Vance Dividend Builder A Report

RETURN

: 2.1%

ASSETS

: $1.3 billion

MANAGER

: Judith Saryan, since March 1999; Charles Gaffney (August 2007)

TOP STOCKS

:

Apple

(AAPL) - Get Apple Inc. Report

, 3.3%,

IBM

(IBM) - Get International Business Machines Corporation Report

, 2.7%, and

Prudential

(PRU) - Get Prudential Financial Inc. Report

, 2.4%

BIG WINNER

:

Seadrill

(SDRL) - Get Seadrill Ltd. Report

, 2% of the fund, up 44%.

STRATEGY

: No really big losers, and excluding its largest holding,

Apple

, no big winners, but it earns it way to a gain as a "dividend" fund, yielding an impressive 3.8%. Portfolio turnover is a speedy 152%. Most of its 76 stocks are well-known companies. Financial services is the largest sector weighting, at 16%, followed by industrial materials, at 13%.

5.

EATON VANCE TAX-MANAGED VALUE

(EATVX) - Get Eaton Vance Tax-Mgd Value A Report

RETURN

: 2.1%

ASSETS

: $1.8 billion

MANAGER

: Michael Mach, since 2000; and John Crowley, Matthew Beaudry, Stephen Kaszynski, all January 2010.

TOP STOCKS

:

Johnson & Johnson

(JNJ) - Get Johnson & Johnson Report

, 2.5%,

Wells Fargo

(WFC) - Get Wells Fargo & Company Report

, 2.5%, and

Pfizer

(PFE) - Get Pfizer Inc. Report

, 2.5%

BIG WINNER

:

Union Pacific

(UNP) - Get Union Pacific Corporation Report

, 1.7% of the fund, up 50%.

STRATEGY

: The financial-services sector makes up 26% of the holdings, which hurt its performance, followed by health care, at 13%. The fund holds 81 stocks and only 24% of its assets are in the top 10 so it's spread thinly.

Eight of the top 25 holdings have fallen.

Bank of America

(BAC) - Get Bank of America Corporation Report

is its only big loser, but it has few big winners, except for the railroad conglomerate

Union Pacific

(UNP) - Get Union Pacific Corporation Report

. The fund's yield of 1.1% is offset by expenses of 1.2%.

4.

JANUS ASPEN FORTY INSTITUTIONAL

(JACAX) - Get Janus Henserson VIT Forty Inst Report

RETURN

: 1.9%

ASSETS

: $1.1 billion

MANAGER

: Ron Sachs, since January 2008

TOP STOCKS

:

Apple

(AAPL) - Get Apple Inc. Report

, 11%,

Celgene

(CELG) - Get Celgene Corporation Report

, 6.4%, and

Anheuser-Busch

(ABT) - Get Abbott Laboratories Report

, 5.5%

BIG WINNER

:

Ford

(F) - Get Ford Motor Company Report

, 2.5% of the fund, up 68%.

STRATEGY

: Another highly focused fund, with half of its assets in the top 10 stocks. The fund has an impressive array of stocks in its top 25, but other than

Apple

, up 50%, and

Ford

, up 68%, there are no impressive returns. It's been hurt by bets on the computer hardware sector, at 19% of the fund, and financial services, also 19%.

3.

GMO QUALITY III

(GQETX) - Get GMO Quality III Report

RETURN

: 1.1%

ASSETS

: $15 billion

MANAGER

: William Joyce, since 2004; Sam Wilderman (2005), Thomas Hancock (2009)

TOP STOCKS

:

Oracle

(ORCL) - Get Oracle Corporation Report

, 5.7%,

Microsoft

(MSFT) - Get Microsoft Corporation Report

, 5.6%, and

Johnson & Johnson

(JNJ) - Get Johnson & Johnson Report

, 5.4%

BIG WINNER

:

Philip Morris

(PM) - Get Philip Morris International Inc Report

, 1.7% of the fund, up 25%.

STRATEGY

: The fund holds 78 stocks but it's very concentrated as the top 10 make up 43% of its holdings. Health care is a huge sector bet, at 29%, followed by consumer goods, at 24%.

Microsoft

, at 5.6% of the fund and its second-largest holding, is down 9.5% this year. Twelve of the stocks in the fund's top 25 have declined, although the list reads like a who's who of blue-chip stocks.

Apple

(AAPL) - Get Apple Inc. Report

is the fund's big winner, but it only makes up 2.2% of the fund. The next biggest return comes from cigarette producer

Philip Morris

(PM) - Get Philip Morris International Inc Report

, with a 25% return, but it's only 1.7% of assets. The fund yields a decent 1.83%, and expenses are low, at 0.48%.

2.

JANUS FORTY

(JARTX) - Get Janus Henderson Forty S Report

RETURN

: 1%

ASSETS

: $7 billion

MANAGER

: Ron Sachs, since December 2007

TOP STOCKS

:

Apple

(AAPL) - Get Apple Inc. Report

, 11%, cash, 7.7%, and

Celgene

(CELG) - Get Celgene Corporation Report

, 5.6%

BIG WINNER

:

Limited Brands

(LTD)

, 2.6% of the fund, up 73%.

STRATEGY

: Another fund that has seesawed over the past three years, it lost 44% in 2008, and blazed ahead in 2009. It's very focused, holding only 39 stocks, and the top 10 holdings make up 49% of the portfolio. It has a 40% portfolio turnover rate. Without the outsized bet on

Apple

, the returns could have been a lot worse. A 7.7% allocation to cash doesn't help returns.

Janus Forty is yet another fund hurt by a big bet on financial-services stocks, which make up 18% of the fund. Computer hardware is the largest sector allocation, at 20%.

1.

INVESCO BASIC VALUE

(GTVLX)

RETURN

: 0.5%

ASSETS

: $1.2 billion

MANAGER

: Matthew Seinsheimer, since 2001; Devin Armstrong, James Warwick, Jason Leder, Kevin Holt, all since June 2010

TOP STOCKS

:

Chubb

(CB) - Get Chubb Limited Report

, 4.3%,

Omnicomm

(OMC) - Get Omnicom Group Inc. Report

, 4.1%, and

JPMorgan Chase

(JPM) - Get JP Morgan Chase & Co. Report

, 3.9%

BIG WINNER

:

Time-Warner Cable

(TWC)

, 3.2% of the fund, up 64%.

STRATEGY

: An extremely volatile fund over the past few years, perhaps indicative of its bottom-up contrarian approach and management changes, it lost 52% in 2008, and rose by the same amount in 2009. Its management team was shuffled this year after Invesco acquired the Van Kampen funds from Morgan Stanley, resulting in the addition of four managers in June.

A concentrated fund with only 47 stocks, and a third of the portfolio in its top 10 holdings, it has a low portfolio turnover rate of 21%. A big bet on financial-services stocks, at 29% of the fund, including

Bank of America

(BAC) - Get Bank of America Corporation Report

and

JPMorgan Chase

, hobbled performance. Its best performer is

Time-Warner Cable

, followed by

Honeywell

(HON) - Get Honeywell International Inc. Report

, up 34%.