Editor's note: As part of our partnership with PBS's Nightly Business Report, TheStreet's Jeanine Poggi spoke with NBR's Tom Hudson (watch video and read transcript) about defensive retail ETF plays.
NEW YORK (TheStreet) -- Retail stocks are never easy to play, with so much of a company's performance based on hard-to-predict and ever-changing trends. And with consumer confidence stubbornly low and retailers across the board once again finding themselves needing to discount, trading stocks within the sector has become increasingly more difficult.
The second quarter didn't provide much to look forward to, with few retailers reporting heroic numbers -- and most, not surprisingly, issuing cautious outlooks.
Thus, for those who believe the U.S. economy is poised for a double-dip, cherry picking retail stocks should be avoided. For those who are seeking to diversify their portfolio with some retail stocks, a less aggressive, defensive ETF like
is a safer bet.
RTH is heavily weighted in non-discretionary retailers like
, which comprises slightly more than 20% of the holding, and
, at 9.4% of the portfolio.
Retail HOLDRs also has a small stake in some second-quarter superstars like
RTH is down 7% for the year-to-date perdiod, while the S&P Retail Index is down 3.5% for the same time.
Other safer ETFs include
Consumer Staples Select
Vanguard Consumer Staples
. However, these are not pure plays on the retail sector, consisting mostly of consumer product companies like
Procter & Gamble
XLP only has 25% of its portfolio allocated to retailers, while retailers comprise a mere 20% of the holding at VDC.
Investors who are more bullish on the prospects of a consumer recovery and hope to catch it early can look to the
SPDR S&P Retail ETF
. This is a pure-play on retail with broad exposure, with 65 holdings in diverse retailers, from
The upside of XRT is that it distributes its assets relatively evenly, with its top holding,
, comprising just 2.7% of its total assets.
XRT is up 1.2% for the year-to-date period.
Still, investors should only look to the XRT if they have "nerves of steel," says Morningstar analyst Robert Goldsborough. The XTR is a vote of confidence on the slow but steady recovery.
Goldsborough, for his part, suggests owning XRT further into a double dip, not when there is so much uncertainty out there.
--Written by Jeanine Poggi in New York.
>To contact the writer of this article, click here:
>To follow the writer on Twitter, go to
>To submit a news tip, send an email to: