Bank of America's
sour third-quarter earnings results announced on Monday confirm what may already be obvious for many: Things are getting worse, not better, for banks as the credit crunch passes its one-year anniversary.
Wall Street and the media have been consumed recently, wondering about the ongoing viability of several large banks as investors panicked over the liquidity of financial institutions and overall viability. Beginning next week, with
on Wednesday, banks will reveal just how bad earnings for the sector were in the third quarter.
filed for bankruptcy while
was seized by regulators. Just last week,
teetered on the brink of failure, before the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. brokered a deal with
Large multinational banks have been scooping up their departed rivals' remains. JPMorgan Chase agreed to purchase WaMu,
purchased portions of Lehman, while Citi and Wells Fargo, who trumped Citi's $2.16 billion deal with a $15.1 billion offer later in the week, remain in a legal battle for
The collapse of several large banks exemplifies just how dire the situation has become for the sector, amid an increasingly dour economic environment. Analysts at Fox-Pitt Kelton Cochran Caronia Waller estimate that overall earnings for the bank sector will fall 28% compared to a year earlier.
"While the fundamental outlook for most banks remains negative due to falling real estate prices, limited balance sheet growth and funding pressures, the stocks are likely to trade more on technical factors, including the perceived benefit of
the federal bailout legislation and the removal of the short-sale ban," the analysts wrote in an industry note Tuesday.
Still, the firm's analysts said they "do not expect many banks to discuss the 2009 outlook and those that do are likely to give a sobering sense of reality."
Capital raises remain prevalent in the banking sector, particularly as the credit environment gets worse. Throughout the rest of the year and into next year, credit costs will remain high, as the troubles seen in subprime and residential construction loan portfolios spread to other areas, including credit cards and prime mortgages, analysts say.
Several large banks have already warned of third-quarter troubles.
reported earnings ahead of schedule, and the results were not pretty. The bank earned $1.18 billion, or 15 cents a share, down by more than two-thirds from the year-earlier period. BofA also announced plans to sell up to $10 billion of common stock and slash its dividend in half to 32 cents a share to shore up capital as credit losses intensify.
Oppenheimer analyst Meredith Whitney estimates that recent capital raises between
, JPMorgan Chase and BofA total $45 billion. In addition, depending on which bank wins Wachovia, Citi expects to raise an additional $10 billion, while Wells Fargo said it would raise $20 billion in capital.
"With such massive capital raises, we believe a 'sooner is better' mentality will prevail, as far as capital raises, and distinguish survivors and the more challenged among banks," Whitney writes in a note Tuesday.
Bank of America
Charlotte, N.C.-based BofA, which bought ailing mortgage lender
in July and announced plans last month to purchase
( MER) for roughly $50 billion, said that credit quality is continuing to deteriorate as economic conditions drastically worsen.
Loan portfolios showing trouble spots such as home equity, subprime mortgage and homebuilders have "spread" to include first mortgage residential portfolios, unsecured consumer lending and credit card portfolios, BofA said.
The company added nearly $2 billion to its allowance for loan losses in the three months ending Sept. 30.
"The economy has moved to a recessionary environment and the risk of a prolonged recession has increased," BofA said in the earnings release. "Consumers are experiencing higher levels of stress from depreciating home prices, rising unemployment and tighter credit conditions. Higher levels of bankruptcies are occurring and delinquencies and losses have increased in all consumer portfolios."
Citi snuck in third-quarter earnings guidance last Monday on a conference call to discuss its intentions to purchase Wachovia's banking operations. The New York bank said that continued deterioration in consumer credit had a "significant" negative impact on profit this quarter.
Citi's net loss is expected to range between $2.5 billion and $5.1 billion. The company expects credit costs to be as much as $10 billion for the third quarter, up from $7 billion in the second quarter. Citi says roughly half of the increase is due to loan-loss reserve building, primarily due to worsening metrics in its credit card and residential mortgage businesses, while the remaining half is due to higher net charge-offs than the company expected.
The financial titan, one of the worst-hit banks throughout the credit crisis, has taken approximately $61 billion in securities writedowns and credit losses as of the end of September, according to
The Fox-Pitt analysts perceive the third quarter as "an inflection point" for Citi as the "focus shifts from writedowns to credit costs," according to the industry note. Still "
we would continue to recommend patience as both Citi's issues and the macro environment will surely take some time to turn around."
WaMu, before it was seized by regulators, ironically said in early September that it expected its third-quarter provision for credit losses to be $4.5 billion -- $1.4 billion less than the provision it took in the prior quarter. The company expected total loan-loss reserves to rise from $8.5 billion at June 30 to approximately $10.3 billion at the end of the third quarter.
But while the thrift had added less to its reserves for losses on residential mortgages, WaMu was still beefing up its reserve levels for credit card losses.
Analysts expect JPMorgan Chase to post a loss this quarter on the heels of the WaMu and
JPMorgan Chase has been one of the few banks that have managed to keep its head above water in these difficult times. The stalwart bank agreed in September to pay the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. $1.9 billion for WaMu's deposits, assets and other liabilities, after completing a deal to buy Bear Stearns this spring in yet another government-backed deal.
The New York-based bank said it will take writedowns of $31 billion against WaMu's $242 billion average loan portfolio. The writedowns "primarily represents our estimate of remaining credit losses related to the impaired loans," it said.
Additionally, JPMorgan Chase also said in preliminary results announced at the same time as the WaMu deal that net charge offs in its retail franchise are continuing to trend higher. The bank plans to add roughly $600 million to its allowance for loan losses to prepare for further losses in its subprime and prime mortgage portfolios, it said. It also plans to take $3 billion to $3.5 billion in writedowns on mortgage-backed securities and leveraged loans. JPMorgan Chase reiterated that card losses will be roughly in the 5% range, among other things.
"We see JPMorgan Chase as a relative winner in the current stressed market conditions," according to Richard Staite, an analyst in London at Atlantic Equities, in a note where he upgraded the stock to overweight following the deal announcement.
"Its size, financial strength and diversity ensure it is seen as a safe haven counterparty for clients that range from the man on the street to hedge funds," Staite wrote.
Wells Fargo, another stalwart in the banking industry, could have "depressed" results from further deterioration in home prices, the Fox-Pitt analysts write.
The San Francisco-based bank, while sticking to relatively stringent lending standards even during the credit boom, was not immune to the credit crisis. One hangover the bank has is in regards to its home equity portfolio, specifically so-called brokered home-equity loans.
Wells Fargo had already separated what it perceives to be the worst of the home equity lot into a $12 billion-liquidating portfolio, but the Fox-Pitt analysts are nevertheless concerned about the remaining home equity exposure totaling $84 billion. The analysts estimate that roughly $24 billion is in a second-lien position, "not behind a Wells Fargo first" mortgage, they write.
On a positive note, the surviving big banks are gaining deposit market share as investors begin to dump their deposits into what are perceived as safer banking institutions.
Organic retail bank deposits at BofA rose $21 billion -- which excludes the $35 billion in deposits the bank gained from its Countrywide acquisition -- during the third quarter. The bank estimates the gain was "almost three times the industry average," it said.
BofA management "believes that the strong deposit growth seen in the
third quarter and over the first few days of the
fourth quarter was the result of a flight to safety by depositors and that this shift is producing faster-than-
expected organic growth in both retail and commercial customers, " Whitney writes in a note discussing BofA's earnings release.
Indeed, from Sept. 15 through Sept. 25, the day WaMu was seized by regulators, the Seattle-based thrift had deposit outflows of $16.7 billion, according to the Office of Thrift Supervision.