Updated from 5 p.m. EST
Overture Services (OVER) plunged late Thursday after the company warned of a first-quarter shortfall and said costs would rise in 2003.
The setback came as the company posted fourth-quarter results that were in line with Wall Street estimates and maintained its financial guidance for the whole of 2003. But the prospect of a steep shortfall in the first quarter, and the bad news on so-called traffic acquisition costs, a key component of the bearish case on the stock, knocked Overture down 15% in after-hours trading.
Overture's drop is the latest twist in a volatile Wall Street debate over the long-term prospects for the company, which operates an advertising-supported, pay-per-click search engine that appears on Yahoo! (YHOO), Microsoft's (MSFT) MSN and other Internet properties.
For the fourth quarter ended Dec. 31, earnings fell to $10 million, or 16 cents a share, from $21 million, or 35 cents a share, a year earlier. The latest quarter included a charge related to an unfavorable arbitration ruling regarding a former affiliate; excluding those costs, net income was $15 million, or 24 cents a diluted share. Revenue nearly doubled, to $200 million from $101 million a year earlier; analysts surveyed by Thomson Financial/First Call had expected earnings of 23 cents a share on revenue of $195 million.
More worrisome to investors, though, was the company's first-quarter forecast. Overture said first-quarter earnings would be 13-14 cents a share on revenue of $215 million-$220 million. Wall Street analysts had expected earnings of 23 cents a share on revenue of $223 million.Part of the reason first-quarter profit will be at that level, says Overture, is that the company is investing in new tools for advertisers, and it is speeding up its rollout of international operations. The company says it expects its international operations to be profitable in 2004.
Also problematic was Overture's forecast that traffic acquisition costs, or the amount of money the pay-per-view search engine shares with its business partners, would rise to 63%-64% of revenue in the first quarter. The company had
Key to that rising traffic acquisition cost, say Overture bears, is the increasing share of Overture's revenue coming from its largest partners -- a trend which increases those players' bargaining power in determining the revenue Overture must share with them.
"We've certainly seen an increase in concentration," said CEO Ted Meisel on Thursday, on a call with analysts. But he said that the company was constantly surprised, and "pleasantly so," by the contributions to Overture's revenue from its partnership with smaller players.
News of the shortfall comes during an eventful week for Overture, which earlier noted deals with AOL Europe and ESPN.
Overture, which was trading above $30 in early January, fell 60 cents in regular trading Thursday to $22.38, then dropped to $18.93 in after-hours trading, after the announcement of its results.