NEW YORK ( TheStreet) -- One year ago, I revealed a list of seven companies -- Corning (GLW), Hess (HES), Rowan (RDC), Patterson-UTI (PTEN), Omega Protein (OME), Kelly Services (KELYA) and American Greetings, a company bought out in August -- that were trading below tangible book value per share.
That measure takes the more commonly used book value per share calculation (shareholders equity divided by shares outstanding), and strips out intangible assets such as goodwill, patents and trademarks. The theory here is that intangible assets can have little real value and may skew a company's true book value; it's simply a more conservative view of book value and is often used by the value crowd.
That group of companies has returned an average of 50% since that column ran, versus 28% for the
and 38% for the Russell 2000. Rather than simply screening for companies trading below tangible book, the screen I use for this search includes several other criteria:
- No financial companies
- Long-term debt to equity less than 50%
- Companies must be profitable on a trailing 12-month basis
- Minimum market cap $100 million
Five of the qualifying companies returned more than 50%. Corning, Hess, Patterson, and Kelly were all in the 50% range, while fish oil and fish meal producer Omega Protein more than doubled. The two laggards were Rowan, up 16%, and American Greetings, up 14%. In August, American Greetings was taken private by the Weiss family, who already had controlling interest in the company.
While I am pleased with the results of this screen, I know they occurred in an up market, and the real test is performance when the markets are pulling back. The theory is that tangible book value can create a potential floor value in a stock price; that the price should not deviate too far below tangible book value. Of course, companies in distress can and will deviate from that theory.
In order to avoid such situations, I have included a couple of criteria in my screen -- profitability on a trailing 12-month basis, and debt to equity ratio below 50% -- that should help guard against the inclusion of troubled companies.
Despite the run-ups in stock prices, the six remaining publicly traded companies now trade at an average of 1.23 times tangible book value per share, still on the low side. Rowan is the only remaining company trading below tangible book value.