NEW YORK (
) -- How hated is
(AAPL - Get Report)
This weekend we heard about how it is going to launch larger-screen phones and flexible phones, two well-liked characteristics of competitor
phones. Then we heard from Piper Jaffray, the endless defender of Apple, that it has a new in-home patent that could help Apple develop the living room. That, plus an incredible article about how Apple's solidifying a huge lead in Japan where sales are extraordinarily strong.
And what does the stock do?
Nothing. It is now back entirely to its underperforming ways.
I think this has gotten a little out of control. Just like there were two markets for the longest time -- Apple up, the rest of market to flat to down -- there's now Apple flat-to-down and market up. Doesn't even seem to matter what it does.
Which brings me to a remarkable conclusion: Apple's become hated. There is no other justification for this discount. Apple could bid $35 billion for
, a nice premium to the $25 billion valuation, to which I actually think the stock would jump. I reiterate that even up here if Apple were to buy
at $30 billion it would get the stock going.
Of course, that's the abominable phrase that Apple doesn't want to hear. It doesn't want to "get the stock going." But the company has to free itself from the shackles of financial engineering, and a buy of a super-growth company would be just the thing that's wanted.
Instead, with these constant Carl Icahn updates about talking with Tim Cook, Apple's become the
of computing, nowhere anyone really wants to be except those who want don't care about buying or developing growth.
As much as I like how Icahn has galvanized managements to return cash, I think returning cash the way Icahn wants is a big mistake. It will do nothing for the long term. But sitting on cash isn't going to do anything either.
That's why, as much as I like Apple, unless it stops talking to Icahn and starts talking to bankers about an acquisition that gives it "social," the stock will be dead in the water until estimates come down so far that it can blow them away. And judging by the action -- we aren't there yet.
Action Alerts PLUS which Cramer co-manages as a charitable trust, is long AAPL.
Editor's Note: This article was originally published at 7:50 a.m. EST on Real Money on Nov. 12.