Fourth-best market for renters: El Paso, Texas
Bang for Your Buck score: 68.6
Bang for Your Buck score: 68.7 This oceanfront community popular with vacationers has high average rental values ($1,528 a month), but still manages to come close to the top Zillow's Rental Bang for Your Buck list because of other tenant-friendly factors. For instance, high home prices mean it takes a long 5.12 years to break even buying a place in 447,000-population Virginia Beach instead of renting. Tenants in Virginia's most-populous city have also enjoyed a 0.13% drop in average rental values over the past year, while the typical unit carries a below-average advertised asking rent of 96 cents per square foot. Second-best market for renters: Fayetteville, N.C.
Bang for Your Buck score: 69.9 The home of Fort Bragg has plenty to boast about when it comes to affordable rentals. For instance, Fayetteville is in a three-way tie with Memphis, Tenn., and Birmingham, Ala., in offering the fifth-lowest advertised rents among major U.S. cities. The typical rental there lists for just 65 cents per square foot. Fayetteville's median rental values have also dropped over the past year by 1.51%, the seventh-biggest decline among big cities. All told, the typical residence in this 206,000-person city has a rental value of just $848 a month. That's the 10th-lowest level for any major U.S. city and partly offsets Fayetteville's relatively short estimated break-even period of 2.71 years. Best market for renters: St. Louis
Bang for Your Buck score: 71.3 They may have lost the 2013 World Series, but they're still No. 1 when it comes to rentals. St. Louis takes first place in Zillow's Rental Bang for Your Buck study thanks to a better-than-average performance on almost every metric that the website analyzed. For openers, rental values in this 319,000-population city dropped an estimated 5.15% over the past year -- the second-biggest decline among major U.S. communities. That's helped drive down average St. Louis rental values to a mere $829 a month, the seventh-lowest level for any big city in America. Landlords are also advertising the typical St. Louis rental at just 85 cents per square foot, well below the U.S. average. "St. Louis looks relatively good across the board," Gudell says. The only drawback renters face is the fact that you can break even buying a St. Louis home instead of renting in just 2.76 years. Gudell attributes the short break-even period to St. Louis homes selling for relatively low prices. "The [for-sale] market hasn't seen a strong recovery," she says.