NEW YORK ( The Deal) -- The decision by NYSE Euronext (NYX) to take a stake in ACE Group (ACE - Get Report), announced Monday, Sept. 9. illustrates how stiff competition is pushing exchanges to innovate and diversify their offerings.
By taking a minority stake in ACE's private placement platform, the NYSE is tapping a market worth $1 trillion annually that provides an alternative source of liquidity from the traditional equities market. This market is set to grow in significance as major banks, faced with tough new capital and regulatory requirements, are likely to either re-price lending or tighten their credit criteria.
The transaction comes as exchanges face growing competition from the proliferation of dark pools and new entrants. Last month
BATS Global Markets
Direct Edge Holdings
agreed to merge. That deal, the companies claimed, would put them ahead of
(NDAQ - Get Report)
as the second-largest U.S. equity trading venue and also put them in a position to challenge the lead of NYSE Euronext as an equity trading venue.
Then, there is the biggest exchange deal this year, the $8.2 billion acquisition of NYSE Euronext by Atlanta's
(ICE - Get Report)
, or ICE, which is expected to create one of the largest derivatives exchanges by contracts traded.
Recent trading outages at the Nasdaq have also called the credibility of its platform into question, potentially creating more opportunity for new players. Last month, the exchange halted trading for more than three hours, saying one of its servers was having trouble processing orders. Of course, technological hiccups happen in other trading platforms as well -- last year BATS was about to have an initial public offering when a glitch in its own platform called it to shelve its debut.
Despite clear incentives for M&A among exchanges in a globalized world -- and one where revenue opportunities outside cash and equities trading is increasing -- dealmakers say sensitivity around national sovereignty and regulatory approval remain a hurdle to potential exchange mergers. Take, for example, the Singapore Exchange Ltd.'s failed bid for the Australian Securities Exchange in 2011. And, while the IntercontinentalExchange's bid for NYSE Euronext got the nod from regulators this year, a joint bid from Nasdaq and ICE in 2011 was withdrawn after opposition from U.S. antitrust regulators.