NEW YORK ( TheStreet) -- I love the people at Pandora (P - Get Report), particularly Tim Westergren. For the most part I have nothing but good to say about ASCAP. In fact, ASCAP President Paul Williams impressed me so much that I instantly consider him a personal and professional friend.
That said, I pride myself on calling it as I see it and, as Williams himself has said,
seeking the truth
. And the truth is the back-and-forth that continues to take place across this Internet radio royalty dustup is hardly productive and as bad as, if not worse than, any useless political theater we have seen since mindless babbling over things like swift boats and birth certificates.
Following this Internet radio story has become intellectually painful. It's like watching the interview that
anchor did with the "Muslim" (the impressive professor Reza Aslan) who wrote a book about Jesus over and over and over again.
My recent article history
captures much of the lunacy from the
flat awful media coverage
baseless attacks from Pandora's critics
Pandora's irritating inability to shift the conversation to a more productive place
And there's the FCC. The Federal Communications Commission. I waited until the fourth paragraph to mention the FCC because it's the most irrelevant agency in the history of agencies that actually have enough power to make somewhat relevant decisions.
The latest isn't even worth a link: ASCAP has petitioned the FCC to block Pandora's purchase of an FM radio station in South Dakota because of Pandora's ownership structure. Foreign investors own a combined stake in the company that apparently puts it over the limit that prohibits purchase of an American radio tower.
Whether I agree -- or anybody else for that matter -- agrees or disagrees with ASCAP or Pandora or whatever the FCC decides is neither here nor there. It's time to halt the rhetoric, procedural and legal maneuvers on every single side of this multi-faceted and complicated debate and act.
When I tell Paul Williams he ought to sit down with Tim Westergren, he tells me he can't because of lawyers and lawsuits. When I offer the same suggestion to Westergren, I don't really receive a satisfactory response. This FCC story and my anecdote represent just one illustration of what's wrong with practically each and every aspect of the myriad issues involved here.
We have a better chance of peace between the Israelis and Palestinians than we do a suitable royalty arrangement between distinct Internet radio players such as Pandora and
and groups and boards representing or setting rates for all those involved in the creation and dissemination of music (labels, performers, publishers, songwriters, composers, etc.).