NEW YORK ( ETF Expert) -- Prime Minister Shinzo Abe recently won a landslide reelection in Japan. The victory had been widely anticipated, but the benefits of monetary policy stability is still being scrutinized.
As Abe first came to power, he pressured the Bank of Japan to undertake its largest and most aggressive easing measures in the country's history. The central bank has been creating $70 billion monthly to purchase Japanese debt -- an amount so massive for Japan's economic output that it makes U.S. policy look tame. Shortly after the plan had been leaked, the yen lost roughly 20% of its value and boosted the perception that the stimulus would help Japanese corporations.
Unfortunately for other countries in the region, the rapidly declining yen made it difficult for those neighbors to export goods at competitive rates. Countries like South Korea were particularly hard hit. Granted, there may be exceptions. For the most part, however, Asian stocks have been among the world's weakest while Japanese stocks have topped nearly all challengers.
As it stands in 2013, iShares All-Country Asia excluding Japan (AAXJ) has offered -7.5% in the same time period that iShares MSCI Japan (EWJ) has gained 20%. The dollar-hedged WisdomTree Japan Hedged Equity (DXJ) is up about 32%. Indeed, it's difficult to see how Japan's massive quantitative easing can be viewed as a net positive to Asian neighbors. Nevertheless, some commentators are now making the case that Southeast Asia is benefiting from extreme stimulus by the world's third-largest economy. Aaron Back at WSJ.com argues that the extra liquidity of money creation will eventually flow throughout the region, not only through direct investment, but also through large financial institutions with a global presence. Back suggests that the lenders can borrow at ultra-low rates domestically and then lend out the money at higher interest rates throughout Southeast Asia. He cites $8 billion having been spent in the prior eight months by Mitsubishi and Sumitomo to build stakes in financial companies in Thailand, Indonesia and Vietnam. On the other hand, if Japanese money printing and subsequent debt acquisition is such a boon to Southeast Asian economies, one has to wonder why the International Monetary Fund has lowered its global growth forecasts for 2013 and 2014. Similarly, the majority of non-Japanese stock ETFs in the region have abysmal six-month returns.
|Are Asian Neighbors Genuinely Benefiting From “Abenomics?”|
|Approx 6 Month %|
|iShares MSCI South Korea (EWY)||-10.7%|
|SPDR S&P China (GXC)||-9.7%|
|First Trust Asia Pacific excl Japan (FPA)||-8.2%|
|iShares S&P Asia 50 (AIA)||-7.0%|
|iShares Emerging Market Asia (EEMA)||-6.7%|
|Market Vectors Vietnam (VNM)||-3.3%|
|iShares MSCI Hong Kong (EWH)||-2.8%|
|iShares MSCI Japan (EWJ)||23.0%|
|WisdomTree Japan Hedged Equity (DXJ)||28.5%|