HOUSTON, May 28, 2013 /PRNewswire/ -- Crest Financial Limited, the largest of the independent minority stockholders of Clearwire Corporation (NASDAQ: CLWR), today urged Clearwire's "true minority stockholders" to oppose Sprint's new offer and to take the steps necessary to preserve their rights.
In a letter to stockholders, David K. Schumacher, Crest's General Counsel, said Crest refers to "true minority stockholders" because "Clearwire has stacked the deck in favor of Sprint by including as "minority" stockholders a group holding 13% of the outstanding shares that irrevocably obligated themselves to support Sprint even at the $2.97 per share price. These shares are pledged to support Sprint regardless of the alternatives available and regardless of whether Clearwire's Board recommends supporting Sprint's offer. And Sprint is obligated to purchase these shares for the merger consideration—after they have been counted as the "minority"—if the vote fails and the Sprint-SoftBank merger or an alternative transaction is consummated. That means only one thing: for all intents and purposes these are Sprint shares and their votes should not be counted as minority approval. We have filed suit to challenge Sprint's naked interference with stockholder democracy. The presiding judge has indicated that, in the Court's eventual review of the transaction's fairness, the inclusion of these shares in the minority vote count may compromise any benefit Clearwire and Sprint would assert from the vote. We are evaluating all options to provide you with better clarity about who is truly eligible to be counted as non-Sprint stockholders. Sprint must not be allowed to have its cake and eat it too."
Schumacher said: "Of course there is a way forward: We true minority stockholders can reject the current Sprint offer, and the Clearwire Board can allow competitive bidding for Clearwire to begin. SoftBank's CEO Masayoshi Son has suggested publicly that even if we prevail, SoftBank will be 'happy' because Sprint would own 65 percent of Clearwire. According to Son, that will be 'good enough' for him because 'Clearwire would be prohibited to have any sales of frequency to outsiders and so on.' But Masayoshi Son is wrong. Sprint will grab the additional 13% of shares from Intel, Comcast, and Bright House Networks ('BHN') only if Sprint actually consummates the Sprint-SoftBank merger or alternative transaction. And we believe that if Sprint's bid for Clearwire is rejected, neither a Sprint-SoftBank nor Sprint-DISH transaction will ever actually materialize. In that event, Intel, Comcast, and BHN would be free to maintain their collective 13% of the minority shares in an independent Clearwire. These 13% stockholders, after all, are the same stockholders who made significant investments in Clearwire as parties to the Equityholders' Agreement even before the Company's value became clear. Now that the Company's value is clear, it stands to reason that they would support pursuing value through an independent Clearwire once Sprint's gambit to divert Clearwire's value to itself is up. In the end, once the battle for control of Sprint is resolved, Sprint could end up exactly where it is today—with at most 50.2% ownership of Clearwire—and Intel, Comcast, and BHN could retain their rights under the Equityholders' Agreement and an independent Clearwire could pursue value for all stockholders, not just Sprint."
Schumacher also said any vote in favor of the merger agreement would limit minority stockholders' range of options to recover the fair value of shares if Sprint succeeds in its unfair bid for Clearwire. According to Schumacher, "Any vote in favor of the merger agreement would limit your range of options to recover the fair value of your shares if Sprint succeeds in its unfair bid for Clearwire. Delaware law states that only Clearwire stockholders who vote AGAINST the Sprint-Clearwire merger or ABSTAIN can elect to exercise their appraisal rights. Crest has already taken all necessary steps to perfect its appraisal rights under Delaware law. This means that, instead of pursuing damages for breaches of fiduciary duty by Sprint and the Clearwire Board through a class action or individual action, Crest can ask the Delaware Court of Chancery to determine the fair value of its Clearwire common stock if the Sprint-Clearwire merger is consummated and certain other conditions are satisfied. But appraisal rights are by definition individual rights. You must perfect your own appraisal rights and cannot vote in favor of the merger if you are to carry on the fight for fair value in an appraisal proceeding."Schumacher added: "Crest and other stockholders who believe that the merger consideration is inadequate have options for judicial relief, including: (a) appraisal, which is an individual action seeking a fair value determination for only the complaining stockholder ( i.e., any relief would not be available to a class of stockholders); (b) individual lawsuits seeking damages and other relief for breaches of fiduciary duty by Sprint and the Clearwire Board for only the complaining stockholder (as Aurelius Capital Management LP has filed); and (c) a class action lawsuit seeking damages and other relief for breaches of fiduciary duty by Sprint and the Clearwire Board (as several stockholders, including Crest, have filed). As the ongoing battle for Clearwire's future proceeds, Crest continues to weigh all litigation options, including an appraisal proceeding or an individual action." Schumacher concluded: "Crest encourages Clearwire's other true minority stockholders to oppose the merger and to act now to perfect their rights to pursue fair treatment through all available avenues, including an appraisal proceeding."
Check Out Our Best Services for Investors
- $2.5+ million portfolio
- Large-cap and dividend focus
- Intraday trade alerts from Cramer
Access the tool that DOMINATES the Russell 2000 and the S&P 500.
- Buy, hold, or sell recommendations for over 4,300 stocks
- Unlimited research reports on your favorite stocks
- A custom stock screener
- Model portfolio
- Stocks trading below $10
- Intraday trade alerts