Updated to reflect Tesla 8-K filing with the SEC and DOE loan repayment
NEW YORK (
) -- As
(TSLA - Get Report)
repays nearly $500 million in government loans, the Elon Musk-founded automaker will be just a prime example of successful government stimulus.
Tesla could have been worth a lot more when it comes to the bottom line for taxpayers, even if the government's financial backing may have helped to create the nation's fourth automaker to supplant the Big Three of
(F - Get Report)
(GM - Get Report)
, according to Morgan Stanley analysts.
When Tesla repaid $465 million in Department of Energy loans nine years ahead of schedule on Wednesday, the company extinguished
highly profitable stock warrant contracts
the government held in the fast-rising automaker.
The government had held 3,085,011 Tesla warrants, some of which Tesla carried an exercise price of $7.54 and some that carry an exercise of price of $8.94 a share.
At Tesla's current share price of about $90, those warrants would be in the money by about $250 million, helping the government to recoup any losses in about $30 billion in financing it doled out in the wake of the financial crisis to commercialize the electric car and spur on investment in infrastructure.
Late on Wednesday, Tesla said the warrant contracts have expired unexercised in accordance with the terms of its DOE loan grant.
Tesla CEO Musk said in a "tweet " Monday that the company would repay the loan after raising about
in private capital through a stock and convertible note offering earlier this month. Musk is
investing $100 million
in Tesla's capital raise, according to a May 15 company statement.
With the warrants expired, only $12 million in interest payments made by Tesla will remain on the government's books for its near half-billion loan. Those loans, made under the DOE's Advanced Technology Vehicle Manufacturing Program (ATVM) were issued at about the government's long-term borrowing rate.
In total, Tesla will have provided the government marginal return for a significant outlay made in President Barack Obama's oft-criticized stimulus program.
In hindsight, Tesla was clearly worthy of the government's support, especially at a time when private capital for new business was extremely scarce. [The ATVM loans were granted during the Bush administration, but paid out as part of a 2009 stimulus under Obama]
While little evidence will remain of the government's backing of Tesla, the DOE loan, nonetheless, leaves behind the most exciting new U.S. automaker in over a generation, if not a century.
were even bigger recipients of DOE loans made under its ATVM program and a Ford executive
in April the low-cost financing helped the automaker electrify its fleet and build new plant and equipment.