Hualapai Nation Ordered To Pay $28.6 Million To Grand Canyon Skywalk Developer For First Four Years Of Management Fees
PHOENIX, Feb. 12, 2013 /PRNewswire/ -- In a stunning blow to the Hualapai Nation, U.S. District Court Judge, David Campbell has confirmed the $28.6 million arbitration award entered against the Tribe's wholly-owned corporation 'Sa' Nyu Wa, Inc. (SNW) in favor of Grand Canyon Skywalk Development (GCSD), builders of the Grand Canyon Skywalk. The judgment relates to unpaid management fees of the Skywalk from 2008-2011.
According to the court's Order, "SNW shall remit damages in the amount of $28,572,810.25 to Grand Canyon Skywalk Development, LLC, as set forth in the Aug. 16, 2012 Arbitration Order." GCSD now plans to go after more than $10 million sitting in a trust account held by SNW to partially satisfy the federal court judgment. GCSD will seek 100 percent of ongoing Skywalk ticket sales to satisfy the balance of the $28.6 million judgment.
Calling SNW's arguments "nonsensical," Judge Campbell roundly rejected SNW's position that the Dec. 31, 2003 Agreement between the parties permits an award of money damages against SNW in arbitration yet prohibits enforcement of that award in any court at any time. "Such a reading does not comport with SNW's clear waiver of sovereign immunity with respect to money damages and cannot be squared with the provisions discussed above," explained Judge Campbell in his Order.The U.S. District Court's decision comes as GCSD launches a website, grandcanyonskywalkfacts.com that is dedicated to accurate reporting of facts regarding the dispute between GCSD and the Tribe. The site presents the developer's perspective and includes links to court decisions, sworn testimony and statements from tribal leaders, key legal documents and links to recent news. According to Mark Tratos, attorney for GCSD, a related action filed in Tribal Court will determine the legality of the Tribe's condemnation claim or taking back of the Skywalk and GCSD's contractual rights. If the Tribal court says that the Tribe's forcible taking of the Skywalk on Feb. 9, 2012 was appropriate, then it will assess a value to be paid GCSD for the rights it will lose over 35 years – estimated to be $277 million. GCSD believes the condemnation action was unlawful and, by virtue of the Tribe filing that action, it has itself become subject to ongoing damages suffered by GCSD along with responsibility to share profits with GCSD going forward. Tratos explains that his client and SNW had a written agreement to operate the Skywalk together that extends for 20 years and requires that they split profits from the Skywalk. GCSD also receives a discount on tickets to the Skywalk and the right to purchase up to 50 percent of the available tickets during the 20 years. Thereafter, GCSD continues to receive its discounted ticket price and the right to purchase up to 50 percent of the tickets for another 15 years.
Check Out Our Best Services for Investors
- $2.5+ million portfolio
- Large-cap and dividend focus
- Intraday trade alerts from Cramer
Access the tool that DOMINATES the Russell 2000 and the S&P 500.
- Buy, hold, or sell recommendations for over 4,300 stocks
- Unlimited research reports on your favorite stocks
- A custom stock screener
- Model portfolio
- Stocks trading below $10
- Intraday trade alerts