That said, it is possible that HP could have been overvalued and perhaps analysts expected much more from HP than its talents and market reach could deliver. That's not a sentiment fitting for a company of its stature, but clearly there was a disconnect as the stock has lost almost 70% of its value since 2010.
What Is HP Today?
Its challenge now is figuring out a way to restore the confidence of Wall Street. Not an easy task at this point, but not impossible. To that end it has been
working hard to prove that it
does not need to be
in order to survive. Unfortunately, in the process, it has tried to become an enterprise computing corporation -- one that follows the mold of
and to a lesser extent
. But it has been unsuccessful.
Now that the turnaround story that it was thought to be is going to take longer than expected, I have to wonder what is HP today? What can it realistically become tomorrow?
Investors are struggling to answer this, but I'm not certain at this point that HP even knows. This is where I think the company should start thinking like Apple and re-invent itself as Apple was able to do over a decade ago with the iPod.
The company recently said it want to re-enter the mobile phone market. Perhaps that will help it generate love on Wall Street and restore credibility. But it's a mistake. HP is not a phone or gadget company -- even less now on the heels of this disappointment. While entering the smartphone market may generate a buzz, it needs to realize it wants no part of Apple and
. At least not until it gets its house in order.
After all, this is the same cutthroat industry that has left for dead once-dominant powers such as
Research in Motion
while leaving little room for anyone else wanting to sniff a piece of the pie. Even
is finding it increasingly difficult to convince the market that it can produce a phone that consumers love.
The company realizes it has important decisions to make, and that it is equally important to set realistic expectations. As sour as its announcement was, it's hard to disagree with its reasons for cutting guidance.
In addition to these moves it has recently put plans in place to consolidate its PC and printing divisions. Likewise, it has also announced a reduction in its workforce with the hopes that the combined moves will help save $3.5 billion in expenses over the next couple of years.
Making a play for HP at this point remains a tough call to make as the stock may not be going anywhere for a while. The growth outlook is not very good and the valuation suggests the company is on the verge of collapse.
However, where growth is absent, it is always welcomed to offset it with cuts in expense. How that materializes in terms of profitability remains to be seen.
For a company that seems to worry such much about tomorrow, it would be in its best interest to figure out what it is today. Today, it's not a stock worth owning. Cue the "Annie" song...
At the time of publication, the author was long AAPL and held no position in any of the other stocks mentioned
This article is commentary by an independent contributor, separate from TheStreet's regular news coverage.