NEW YORK (
) -- Mitt Romney's
plan for housing
might be short on details and not very different from that of the Obama Administration, but at the very least, it suggests a continuation of policies that would keep investors on Wall Street pretty happy.
Take the plan to sell 200,000 government-owned vacant foreclosed homes. The idea is not new. The Federal Housing Finance Agency -- regulator of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac -- is already running a pilot program to sell foreclosed homes to investors who would then rent it out.
But investors are already salivating at the prospect of the program being expanded further. According to analysts at KBW, institutional investors have raised between $6 billion and $8 billion in the last few months to make investments in the single-family REO (Real estate owned) market.
The early entrants in the business include big private equity firms such as
(BX - Get Report)
Kohlberg Kravitz Roberts
(KKR - Get Report)
(OAK - Get Report)
, as well as mortgage REITS such as
(CLNY - Get Report)
Two Harbors Investment
(TWO - Get Report)
KBW estimates that current cash returns on investments are in the 5% to 7% range, but total potential returns could reach 15% to 20% or higher, depending upon leverage and home price appreciation.
Any plan to help finance bulk acquisitions of government-owned foreclosed homes would be a big win for Wall Street.
It may not do much to help renters and homeowners, however.
According to Jed Kolko, chief economist at Trulia, the bulk of government-owned foreclosed homes are not in the urban cities where supply of rental homes is tight, such as New York. And the program is difficult to implement in hard-hit states such as Florida, where the judicial foreclosure process means the government has less foreclosed homes to sell.
The program could help homeowners in neighborhoods where there is a concentration of government-owned homes. The Romney-Ryan housing white paper released Friday cites the Government Accountability Office's finding that vacant properties may reduce prices of nearby homes by $8,600 to $17,000 per property, so any reduction in vacancies could restore home prices in such neighborhoods.
Still, its impact on the overall housing market may be muted. A Goldman Sachs report earlier this year estimated that "shifting all Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac-owned foreclosed properties to the rental market will have the effect of improving housing prices by 0.5% in the first year of the program and 1% in the second year."