NEW YORK (
(HPQ - Get Report)
CEO Meg Whitman has earned
for her efforts to revitalize the troubled tech giant but more drastic changes may still be needed.
Brought in last year to replace the ousted Leo Apotheker, Whitman quickly gave the no. 1 PC maker some much-needed strategic direction. Quickly nixing Apotheker's controversial plan for a potential PC spinoff, the new CEO took the bold move of merging HP's PC and printer divisions. Whitman also opted to open source the acclaimed
operating system and oversaw HP's
In May, Whitman made one of her toughest decisions yet as the Dow component announced plans to cut 27,000 jobs, or 8% of its total workforce, as part of its broader restructuring.
UBS analyst Steven Milunovich acknowledges that Whitman is "making smart moves" such as centralizing the firm's strategy, sales and marketing, but warns that this may not be enough to succeed.
"We question whether HP is 'better together' and that it might be 'smart to be apart,' specifically spinning off printers and PCs," he explained, in a note released on Tuesday. "HP lacks the pure enterprise focus of
(IBM - Get Report)
(EMC - Get Report)
yet will have trouble competing for consumers without strong tablet and phone businesses like
(AAPL - Get Report)
PCs and printers are, of course, key parts of HP, accounting for just over half of the company's second-quarter revenue. The products are also seen as a way for HP to sell additional products and services, particularly in the enterprise market. Analysts, however, have already warned that the PC and printer merger is hardly a
HP is also facing significant financial headwinds, according to Milunovich, as the tech sector wrestles with a
spending climate. Set against this backdrop, the analyst initiated coverage of HP with a sell rating and $16 price target on Tuesday.
HP, he explained, faces an uphill financial battle for a number of reasons. These include declining printer sales, enterprises downsizing their services, execution issues and PC profits coming under pressure.