NEW YORK ( TheStreet) -- Moody's Investor Service slashed the ratings of 15 of the worlds largest banks late on Thursday as part of a long-threatened review of their creditworthiness.
Moody's cut Morgan Stanley (MS - Get Report) by two notches to Baa1, instead of a possible three notch cut. The agency also cut JPMorgan Chase (JPM - Get Report), Citigroup (C - Get Report) and Goldman Sachs (GS - Get Report) by two notches and Bank of America (BAC - Get Report) by a notch in a sweeping ratings change that still gives the nation's largest banks a negative outlook.
The cuts were not the worst case scenario after Moody's announced in February that it was considering downgrades to the worlds largest banks to better reflect the impact of new regulations and the risks of dealing in capital markets amid a worsening debt crisis in Europe and the United States.
While the downgrades could cost banks billions if matched by ratings agencies Standard & Poor's and Fitch, they may not be a panacea, even after bank stocks and the wider markets tumbled in Thursday trading after reports surfaced that cuts could come as early as the market close.The downgrades by Moody's could raise bank borrowing costs as lenders ask for more collateral on borrowings and some investors in short term debt markets diversify from riskier institutions. In a first quarter analyst call, Blackrock (BLK) chief executive Larry Fink said that the world's largest money manager would consider diversifying from some trading partners if they were downgraded. "All of the banks affected by today's actions have significant exposure to the volatility and risk of outsized losses inherent to capital markets activities," said Moody's Global Banking Managing Director Greg Bauer, in a statement. Moody's also downgraded European banking giants UBS (UBS), Credit Suisse (CS), Barclays (BCS), BNP Paribas, HSBC (HBC) and Deutsche Bank (DB) in its global bank ratings reassessment. Notably, it cut Credit Suisse's ratings by three notches. In Thursday trading, markets tumbled on reports that the downgrade would come after the market close, leading the Dow Jones Industrial Average lower by over 250 points, or nearly 2%, in one of the worst trading drops of 2012. The financial sector underperformed the broader market, with the Financial Sector Select ETF (XLF) dropping over 2%, highlighted by an over 3% drop in Citigroup's shares. In February, Moody's put the largest banks in the U.S. and Europe under review for between one and three notch downgrades, citing risky capital markets activities, new regulations that cut at earnings prospects and a worsening of government debt holdings. The cuts put Morgan Stanley and Citigroup at a higher level than Bank of America's Baa2 rating, which at two notches above a speculative grade or 'junk' rating, is the lowest rated of the nation's largest banks. Goldman Sachs fell to A3 and JPMorgan fell to A2, the level that the ratings firm holds for Wells Fargo (WFC), which it didn't subject to review in February. Analysts were mixed on what the downgrades could entail for banking giants. "We think there will be short-term pressure on MS spreads upon Moody's release, but that will be followed by a steady rally in spreads," wrote Sterne Agee analyst Donald Jones, in a Thursday note to clients. CLSA analyst Mike Mayo said that the downgrades have already been priced into bank stocks in a Wednesday note to clients; however, a three notch cut of Morgan Stanley's credit ratings could have been a surprise investors. "The big surprise would be if there is more than a one-notch downgrade for big banks, other than Morgan Stanley, or if another rating agency follows suit sooner than expected," wrote Mayo. In a statement Morgan Stanley said, "while Moody's revised ratings are better than its initial guidance of up to three notches, we believe the ratings still do not fully reflect the key strategic actions we have taken in recent years." In after-hours Thursday trading, Morgan Stanley surged over 3% to $14.43 on its two-notch cut. Others had harsher words for Moody's. "Citi strongly disagrees with Moody's analysis of the banking industry and firmly believes its downgrade of Citi is arbitrary and completely unwarranted," said the bank in a statement, citing its improved risk management, capital and liquidity. In an April note to clients, Bernstein Research analyst Brad Hintz said that a three notch cut of Morgan Stanley's ratings could lead to $5 billion in collateral costs and chip up to 30% from the company's bumper fixed income earnings. Many of Morgan Stanley's derivatives trading units are subject to the Moody's ratings, in contrast to competitors who have pushed such units to higher rated subsidiaries. Previous downgrades have taken markets by surprise. In a March note to clients assessing the impact of a Moody's downgrade, Nomura bank analyst Glenn Schorr calculated that on a downgrade, large bank stocks could drop between 2% to 5%.