8. 2012 Mitsubishi Eclipse
Average paid: $25,232
It looks fast and furious, but don't let those lean lines and tints fool you. If a base-model Eclipse pulls up next to you at a streetlight, its 2.4-liter, 162-horsepower engine isn't going to do much besides wait politely for the light to change and ease through the intersection at a reasonable rate of speed. The 265-horsepower six-cylinder is much more suited to a car this sleek and provides plenty of kick for such a lightweight cruiser.