NEW YORK, April 10, 2012 /PRNewswire/ -- Starboard Value LP (together with its affiliates, "Starboard"), one of the largest shareholders of AOL Inc. ("AOL" or the "Company") (NYSE: AOL) with current ownership of approximately 5.3% of the outstanding shares, today announced that it has delivered a letter to the AOL Board to communicate its views on yesterday's announcement involving the sale of more than 800 of the Company's patents and their related patent applications to Microsoft Corporation. Starboard also announced that it expects to promptly file preliminary proxy materials with the SEC for the election of directors to the AOL Board at the upcoming 2012 Annual Meeting.
The full text of the letter to the Board follows:
April 10, 2012
AOL Inc.770 Broadway New York, NY 10003Attn: Members of the Board of DirectorsTo the Board of Directors, Starboard Value LP, together with its affiliates ("Starboard"), currently owns approximately 5.3% of the outstanding shares of AOL Inc. ("AOL" or "the Company"), making us one of the Company's largest shareholders. As you know, since December 21, 2011, we have voiced, both publicly and privately, our strong belief that the Company is significantly undervalued and that opportunities exist to create value based on actions within the control of management and the Board of Directors (the "Board"). We have been consistent in our view that AOL's portfolio of intellectual property is non-core, extremely valuable, and should be monetized. On February 24, 2012, we sent a letter urging you to explore actions to monetize and unlock the value of AOL's portfolio of more than 800 patents. We noted our belief that AOL's patent portfolio could produce in excess of $1 billion of licensing income if appropriately harvested and monetized. On March 30, 2012, we wrote you a follow-up letter stressing that the Company should explore the monetization of the patent portfolio with a sense of urgency, and should carefully assess any asset sale or divestiture to ensure the most tax-efficient outcome. We were pleased to read yesterday's announcement that AOL has entered into a definitive agreement to sell more than 800 of its patents and their related patent applications to Microsoft Corporation ("Microsoft") for aggregate proceeds of $1.056 billion in cash in a tax efficient manner. The Company will also grant Microsoft a non-exclusive license to its retained portfolio of more than 300 patents and patent applications covering categories including advertising, search, social networking, content generation/management, and mapping, among others. We commend management and the Board for taking this meaningful first step in unlocking value for AOL shareholders. However, the announced sale of the patents does little to address our serious concerns with the Company's poor operating performance and substantial losses in the Display business. We estimate that AOL's Display business is currently losing over $500 million per year, including $150 million in Patch alone. Patch is an unproven and, thus far, unsuccessful business model that is draining valuable resources from the Company. Unfortunately, to date, management and the Board have been unable to meaningfully improve profitability in the Display business and unwilling to consider alternative strategies to realize value from these assets. Conversely, recent public comments by management demonstrate that AOL remains committed to the status quo in its Display business - which we find unacceptable. We believe when adjusted for the pro forma cash balance from the patent sale, AOL's enterprise value is only $1.14 billion as of the closing stock price on April 9, 2012. AOL generated consolidated EBITDA of $387.5 million in fiscal 2011. When excluding losses from the Display business, we estimate EBITDA would have been $932.5 million in fiscal 2011. This implies that, after considering the material increase in stock price and pro forma increase in cash, AOL currently trades at 2.9x Enterprise Value / Consolidated EBITDA or 1.2x Enterprise Value / EBITDA (excluding Display losses). This valuation does not include any additional value for AOL's Display properties, Company-owned real estate, or any further monetization of AOL's remaining intellectual property. The underperforming Display business appears to be substantially weighing down AOL's potential valuation. Of additional concern is the potential future use of cash. Pro forma for the patent sale, we estimate that AOL will have approximately $1.43 billion of cash, or $15.35 per share. This represents more than half of the current market capitalization. AOL has a dismal track record of capital allocation, having spent $2.3 billion on acquisitions since 1999 and recording a goodwill impairment charge of approximately $1.4 billion during 2010 alone. Although management stated its intention to "return a significant portion of the proceeds to shareholders," we do not understand why the Company would only return a "significant portion." Why wouldn't the Company simply return all of the proceeds? We remain concerned that shareholder capital will continue to be used for poorly conceived acquisitions and investments into money-losing initiatives like Patch and other Display properties. Again, we applaud management and the Board for taking a big first step towards realizing the full value of AOL for the benefit of all shareholders. We desire nothing more than to continue to be constructive and helpful in ensuring that the best interests of all shareholders are represented on the Board. There remains a substantial opportunity to unlock shareholder value at AOL. The announced sale of AOL's patents does not address the need for substantial improvement in the operating performance of the Company.
Check Out Our Best Services for Investors
- $2.5+ million portfolio
- Large-cap and dividend focus
- Intraday trade alerts from Cramer
Access the tool that DOMINATES the Russell 2000 and the S&P 500.
- Buy, hold, or sell recommendations for over 4,300 stocks
- Unlimited research reports on your favorite stocks
- A custom stock screener
- Model portfolio
- Stocks trading below $10
- Intraday trade alerts