NEW YORK -- (
) -- Craft beer is a fickle mistress, and nowhere is that more evident than among our Beer Dance beer bracket's Final Four.
It's an industry where favored beer styles change with season and whim. Where a long-established brewery can be immediately challenged by a fresh-faced upstart, but can turn the tables with one small batch of the right brew. It's a world where, as
(SAM - Get Report)
founder Jim Koch has said on several occasions, the favorite beer of a large subset of the consumer base is the beer it had last.
This is about the only way we can make heads or tails of last week's results. Portland, Ore., and its huge craft beer community sat on the sidelines for much of last week as
-- one of the oldest in the city -- watched its IPA fall to the mighty Kilt Lifter from
Four Peaks Brewery
in Atlanta was up by 15 votes heading into Friday and had sent us a press release about an expansion that could increase capacity to 500,000 barrels. That would make their operation nearly three times larger than Delaware-based craft beer darling
and roughly the size of Texas regional beer mainstay
, which is considered the fifth-largest craft brewer in the nation by
Beer Marketer's Insights
and produces Texas favorite Shiner Bock.
It wouldn't help Sweetwater hold a lead, however, as fans of New Orleans powerhouse
erased a 15-vote deficit on the last day and forced a four-hour overtime vote. Abita's Turbodog wound up besting Sweetwater's 420 Extra Pale Ale by nine votes and harshing its very pleasant buzz.
Now the bracket that began with a very crowded case of 14 craft brews is down to a four-pack. What was once a fine balance of hops and malt is now a predominantly sweet and malty field with just a bit of hops thrown in for good measure. The drinkers know what they like and even with winter slowly yielding to spring, they're still not ready to pour out that caramel, chocolate and baked-goods flavor just yet.
It's been a tough slog, but here are the four shippable, savvy brews still standing: