They have sought to find some hidden time bomb, some rattling skeleton that might cast a shadow over this $5 billion stock offering, one of the biggest of all time.
Well, here's the surprising, man-bites-dog verdict: Facebook's debut as a public company is actually getting praise from an unlikely source -- not so much for what's in the prospectus, but for what's not there. Unlike a growing number of companies, especially (but by no means exclusively) in Silicon Valley, Facebook doesn't resort to non-GAAP financial metrics, which critics among analysts and accountants have long contended are subject to abuse.
The abuses of non-GAAP metrics require regulatory action -- as I'll be coming to in a moment. But, first, let's bask in the glow of this good news.The lack of fancy accounting is one less hurdle that Facebook has to surmount as it faces its debut in the markets, which is expected in a few months. It means that Facebook is not likely to draw the kind of criticism that has beset the coupon-generator Groupon (GRPN - Get Report), which was skewered last year for trying to use what it called "adjusted consolidated segment operating income," a non-GAAP metric that obscured the company's marketing costs. J. Edward Ketz, an accounting professor and co-author of the Grumpy Old Accountants blog, has been a vociferous critic of Groupon. But he believes that Facebook -- which, he notes, was audited by the same firm, Ernst & Young -- uses straitlaced GAAP-compliant metrics, and none of Groupon's smoke-and-mirrors. As a matter of fact, he has gone on his widely followed blog, which he writes with fellow prof Anthony H. Catanach Jr., to proclaim that Facebook gets an "A" for its straightforward accounting. They noted that Facebook "does NOT use the term EBITDA (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization) or adjusted EBITDA anywhere in its securities filing" -- suggesting that Facebook has "absolutely no problem reporting its performance using income amounts computed using generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP). When was the last time we saw an Internet company NOT make excuses about how GAAP failed to reflect reality for their operations?" What's more, he notes, Facebook actually recognizes revenue in a simple, straightforward manner. "There are no multiple deliverable issues as in the case of LinkedIn (LNKD - Get Report), or the 'gross vs. net' questions that plagued Groupon," he points out. There's also no hocus-pocus in reporting cash flow, no "special items" or off-balance-sheet transactions. Now, that doesn't mean that everything is perfect in the Facebook prospectus. Ketz notes that compensation levels, which include a hefty amount of stock-based income, may raise questions as to whether executive compensation is excessive. And then there is the matter of how Facebook defines users. Not long after the prospectus was released, Barry Ritholtz pointed out on his blog that Facebook seems to be grossly inflating the number of people it counts as "active users." But Ketz pointed out to me that he doesn't believe that Facebook should be valued on the basis of its user count or any other non-GAAP metric. "Valuation depends on future cash flows and I don't see what users, however defined, tells me about future cash flows," he says. Groupon ultimately abandoned the "adjusted consolidated" yadda yadda metric after it drew regulatory scrutiny, which didn't do its earnings much good, but that didn't convert Ketz into a fan. In a blog post in August, he pointed to continuing accounting issues at Groupon and referred to "the deafening silence in the accounting, auditing, and investment communities about the company's questionable basic accounting practices and lack of internal reporting controls." Ketz has similarly been critical of the IPO prospectus generated last year by Zynga (ZNGA - Get Report), an Internet game developer that whose financial statements have relied on "adjusted EBITDA," a non-GAAP measure he considers worthless. In one blog post, he and Catanach pointed out that "Zynga is actually trying to map the virtual world of fantasy and dreams to the real world of cold cash and hard knocks" -- and not succeeding terribly well. Non-GAAP measures have been the bane of Silicon Valley and Internet firms over the years, and have been the cause of confusion and angst on many occasions. They have been the bane of the Internet retailer Overstock.com (OSTK - Get Report), whose use of non-GAAP measures has been severely criticized by former Crazy Eddie accounting mastermind Sam Antar, as he has recounted in detail on his blog. Although Overstock CEO Patrick Byrne once criticized EBITDA as "the stupidest thing I ever heard emanate from Wall Street," he subsequently used that non-GAAP measure -- and he has never been confronted with his criticism of EBITDA at the company's quarterly conference calls. Gradient Analytics, an independent research firm that has skewered Overstock's accounting in the past (and fought a costly legal battle as a result), recently issued reports blasting use of non-GAAP metrics at two widely divergent companies: TeleTech Holdings (TTEC - Get Report), a business process outsourcing company, and Mohawk Industries (MHK), a floor-coverings manufacturer. In a research report a couple of weeks ago, Gradient analyst Nicholas Yee opined that the "non-GAAP 'adjusted earnings' figures provided by
Check Out Our Best Services for Investors
- $2.5+ million portfolio
- Large-cap and dividend focus
- Intraday trade alerts from Cramer
Access the tool that DOMINATES the Russell 2000 and the S&P 500.
- Buy, hold, or sell recommendations for over 4,300 stocks
- Unlimited research reports on your favorite stocks
- A custom stock screener
- Model portfolio
- Stocks trading below $10
- Intraday trade alerts
Check Out Our Best Services for Investors
Every recommendation goes through 3 layers of intense scrutinyquantitative, fundamental and technical analysisto maximize profit potential and minimize risk.
Our options trading pros provide over 100 monthly option trading ideas and strategies to help you become a well-seasoned trader.