'Mortgage Deal from Hell' Hurts Responsible Borrowers: Bove

By Jeff Cox, CNBC.com Senior Writer

NEW YORK (CNBC) --Homeowners who kept up on their payments would lose while those who fell behind would win under an apparent deal between big banks and state governments, banking analyst Dick Bove said.

The agreement, expected to be worth at least $26 billion, would compensate both victims of alleged foreclosure fraud and underwater homeowners whose debt exceeds the value of their properties.

While the agreement is being hailed in some circles as justice for those duped into buying overvalued homes, Bove, the vice president of equity research at Rochdale Securities, thinks the deal is misguided.

More from CNBC Mortgage Plan Gives Homeowners Bulk of the Benefits As Mortgage Refinancings Surge, Banks Struggle US Jobs Gap Between Young and Old Is Widest Ever

"Those people lucky or smart enough to stop making payments on their homes may get their loan balances reduced," he said. "Other beneficiaries of the agreement may be homeowners who have seen the value of their houses drop below the size of their mortgages. They get a freebie that other homeowners who have paid their mortgages down will not get."

Begun in 2010 as an investigation into foreclosure practices, discussion between state attorneys general across the country and the banks evolved into trying to find ways to help underwater borrowers as well.

The deal is believed to include some $20 billion in mortgage refinancings and principal writedowns to discourage struggling homeowners from walking away from their obligations.

But Bove, who called the agreement "the mortgage deal from hell," said doing so will help those who bought homes with little money down and who either fell behind on payments or stopped paying their mortgages altogether.

Those who brought down their principal with 20 percent down payments and who kept up on their obligations would not benefit, and ultimately could suffer if the mortgage modifications and principal writedowns drag down neighborhood property values.

"The government has selected a small minority of homeowners to get this benefit (1 million of 75 million or 1.3 percent of the total)," he wrote in an analysis. "Homeowners who made large down payments on their homes or made the terrible mistake to pay down the principal on their mortgages do not qualify. Homeowners who made minimal or no down payments will get the windfall benefit of a lower principal repayment or a cash payment."