"We expect a pickup in the pace of merger activity among smaller banks."
Those on the lookout for mega-bank deals may be disappointed, but smaller regional banks may soon come to terms with low valuations, a weak outlook and the costs of new regulations, spurring consolidations with larger players, writes Lana Chan of BMO Capital Markets in a January research note.
"Many smaller banks are still struggling with lingering credit issues and weak loan demand from small businesses. In addition, these smaller banks do not have the scale to spread the costs of numerous new banking regulations. These factors should cause many of the affected smaller institutions to look to merge with other banks or sell themselves to larger Banks," writes Chan.
The most likely takeover candidates in 2012 are Wayzata, Minn., -based
(TCB - Get Report)
with $19 billion in assets and New York-based
(STL - Get Report)
with $2.7 billion in assets as a result of a pickup in M&A, "through smaller banks merging or by larger banks acquiring smaller institutions in fill-in deals," writes Chan. BMO Capital Markets rates both banks "market perform", with price targets of $12 a share and $9 a share respectively - less than 12% premiums to current prices.
Potential suitors include
(BBT - Get Report)
(FITB - Get Report)
(MTB - Get Report)
among superregionals and
among small cap banks, adds Chan.
That M&A activity is contingent on targets coming to grips with a diminished outlook on profitability and takeover valuations. Chan notes that "[It] appears that many of these smaller banks have not yet accepted that an environment with slower economic growth, weaker bank profitability, and lower valuations is likely to be normal." Chan adds, "Based on discussions with management teams, there have been fewer than expected mergers involving smaller banks as there is a considerable gap between buyer and seller pricing expectations."
For M&A to pick up, look for the expectations gap to fall, or for a weak outlook on loan demand and still problematic credit and regulatory issues to push some players towards consolidation.
"If I were a stressed bank, I wouldn't expect much interest outside of an assisted deal."
After a wave of mergers among large banks during the crisis, there's been less post-crisis consolidation than many expected as some some banks came near collapse, while others survived with strong prospects. "Doing an open good bank deal is probably pretty challenging right now," says Mark Sponseller a managing director of Alvarez and Marsal's Transaction Advisory Group.