(Editor's note: TheStreet today named 111 mutual funds and exchange traded funds, or ETFs, winners and runners-up in its first annual awards ceremony. A list of the funds and related articles can be found on the awards page.)
NEW YORK (
) -- Van Eck's
Market Vectors Indonesia ETF
debuted a little more than two years ago and, after briefly lagging the standard-bearer
Vanguard Emerging Market ETF
as global stock markets sank, the Indonesia fund has been a homerun for investors. It has surged 270%, twice that of the Vanguard fund.
The Indonesia exchange traded fund
, I noted when it was first released, should be more volatile than emerging market ETFs that hold a wider array of securities. Narrower segments, such as countries and industries, rise and fall more steeply. For example, oil-sands stocks are more volatile than
Energy Sector SPDR
. And, likewise, an Indonesia ETF will rise and fall at a faster pace than a fund made up of several countries' stocks.
This is good on the way up and bad on the way down. As global markets have rallied in the past two years, it stands to reason that the Indonesia ETF would outperform benchmarks. During the next global market sell-off, Indonesian stocks will likely drop more than broader indices. As opposed to being good or bad, this is more of an attribute that needs to be understood and managed.
More recently, Market Vectors Indonesia jumped 42% last year and is up 4.4% this year. Last year's returns and a favorable risk-reward profile earned New York-based Van Eck's exchange traded fund
TheStreet's 2011 Best Fund
award in the
emerging market ETF
category. The runner-up was the
PowerShares Emerging Markets Infrastructure ETF
The makeup of the fund hasn't changed dramatically since 2009. At that time, Market Vectors Indonesia had 34% in financial stocks versus 29% now. It had 16% in energy, 12% in telecommunications and 11% in materials, and now has 11%, 11% and 12%, respectively.
The fund offers a great lesson on the unpredictability of dividends from exchange traded funds. The trailing yield of the index underlying the fund was 7% two years ago, and no one should expect that sort of payout. Indeed, the dividends from the fund have been surprisingly small. The first dividend in 2009 was 6 cents and, a year later, it was 27 cents, making the yield from the last dividend about 1%. In other words, the yield won't shelter investors from a bear-market storm.
The investment case, as well as risks and rewards for Indonesia, haven't been altered dramatically. Like many emerging economies, Indonesia is resource-rich, a benefit since global demand for commodities is increasing. That raises the prosperity of the country's residents, creating a middle class that leads a better life of improved diets and modern infrastructure. The risks include accelerating inflation and political instability.