CHARLOTTE, N.C. (
Bank of America
(BAC - Get Report)
cleared up one item that had been weighing on its stock when reporting quarterly results on Tuesday: Mortgage buyback demands are nowhere near the $70 billion figure
a hedge fund had been tossing around
BofA reported that mortgage buyback demands are less than $13 billion as of Sept. 30.
However, CFO Chuck Noski outlined some information that will keep investors scratching their heads about the firm's total liability. The details came hours ahead of a report regarding private investors' repurchase requests that helped push Bank of America's stock down sharply.
On a conference call Tuesday morning, Noski expressed comfort with estimates related to government-sponsored enterprises (GSEs)
. But he noted that numbers for monoline insurers and private label investors were difficult to pin down, due to litigation and fewer requests to-date.
Noski characterized Bank of America's experience with monoline insurers so far as "episodic" and "all over the map." He added that it was "not possible to reasonably estimate" exposure to private-label buyback requests because Bank of America has had only limited experience with a motley crew of litigious counterparties.
On Monday, a group of institutional investors represented by Gibbs & Bruns LLP said they had sent Bank of America a letter asking that it repurchase $47 billion worth of MBS. On Tuesday afternoon, a
report indicated that the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, Pacific Investment Management Co. (PIMCO),
may be among those seeking buyback relief.
The buyback issue has gained traction in recent months. Large mortgage lenders, including Bank of America,
(JPM - Get Report)
(WFC - Get Report)
, have boosted reserves to cover related losses, even as firm-wide reserves drop by billions. Last week, JPMorgan said it had added $1 billion to reserves against mortgage repurchases, having faced $1.5 billion in related losses during the September quarter.
The buyback issue hinges on similar errors as the documentation mess that has crippled the foreclosure process in recent weeks - but at the point of origination rather than default.
When banks sell MBS or whole loans to other parties, they enter contracts - in most cases pledging that the information therein is accurate and that banks have told investors what they're getting into. Those contracts have "representations and warranties," which require banks to repurchase the debt if there has been some kind of error. As mortgage debt continues to turn sour, investors have been sifting through documents to find such errors and pass bad debt back to lenders.
GSEs, which dominate the MBS market, have been the most aggressive in pushing back souring debt. More than half of BofA's $12.875 billion in outstanding repurchase requests come from Fannie and Freddie. Roughly one-third comes from monoline insurers, which have exposure to mortgage troubles because they "wrap" debt for private investors, effectively providing guarantees against loss. The remaining buyback requests come from private investors who either bought whole mortgages outright or partnered with others to invest in private-label securitizations.