BOSTON ( TheStreet) -- Pension plans, also known as direct-benefit plans, are going the way of the $10 health-insurance co-payment, the thrift savings plan and the lifelong job guarantee.
Companies are increasingly finding pension plans too expensive, too complicated and too risky when compared with 401(k) plans. Dow-member companies dominate the list of those that offer conventional pensions.
A survey by
, the global consulting firm, found that only 17% of Fortune 100 companies still offer a direct-benefit plan, down from 67% in 1998. Those that offer direct-contribution plans, such as 401(k)'s, total 58%, up from 10%. Despite the decline, many of the country's best-known companies still offer pensions to at least some employees.
(GE - Get Report)
, in its annual report, said its plan was fully funded as of Jan. 1 and running effectively enough that it shouldn't have to subsidize it this year or next. It holds assets of $58.3 billion.
Responding to stock-market conditions,
(XOM - Get Report)
contributed $3 billion to its U.S. plans, up from $53 million in 2008.
Other large direct-benefit plans include
(T - Get Report)
(VZ - Get Report)
(F - Get Report)
(LMT - Get Report)
(UPS - Get Report)
Johnson & Johnson
Procter & Gamble
Bank of America
According to Towers Watson, 58 companies in the Fortune 100 currently offer only a direct-contribution plan to new hires. Others are increasingly considering "hybrids," such as
Proponents claim that hybrid plans reduce costs for employers. Participants in cash-balance plans also continued to see their pension accounts grow during the financial crisis, unlike the sizable drops suffered by most 401(k) accounts.
In a cash-balance plan, a participant's account is compensated each year with a set employer contribution and interest credit (either a fixed rate or a variable rate linked to an index such as the 1-year Treasury bill rate). When a participant is eligible to receive benefits under a cash-balance plan, the distribution is either a lump-sum payment or given as an annuity. Investment risk is borne by the employer.
The National Institute on Retirement Security
, a non-profit advocacy group, makes the case that pensions can provide same benefit as individual 401(k) plans at half the cost.
In a research paper,
A Better Bang for the Buck: The Economic Efficiencies of Defined-Benefit Pension Plans
, it says defined-benefit plans pool longevity risks among large numbers of individuals. Because defined-benefit plans, unlike investors, don't age, "they are able to take advantage of the enhanced investment returns that come from a balanced portfolio throughout an individual's lifetime."