Four Strategies for Playing a Tight Stock Market

This was originally published on RealMoney. It is being republished as a bonus for TheStreet.com readers. For more information about subscribing to RealMoney, please click here.

I think the recent run-up in stocks was a bear market rally, in part because the screens and models I use to generate stock ideas aren't giving me much. I usually want a stock to score highly in four out of five categories before giving it much consideration: earnings momentum, earnings quality, price momentum, free cash flow and return potential.

This week [Jun. 9-13], only three stocks went four for five, and I've talked about them all before: W&T Offshore (WTI Quote), Pitney Bowes (PBI Quote) and Rent-a-Center (RCII Quote). As I look for new investment ideas, I'm left with four options, each of which has significant drawbacks.

1. Go Short

I seldom short stocks, but I'll probably try to scratch out some extra gains by writing covered calls on stocks like Ansys (ANSS Quote) that I like long-term, but that look a little stretched in the near term. I also will likely leave a little cash standing by to put to work when conditions are more favorable.

But like many investors, I generally plan to stay long and close to fully invested. In markets like this one, that means shifting gears a little bit.

2. Let Your Winners Ride, Change Strategy

There's always a bull market somewhere, and all it takes to participate is to buy what is working. This can mean averaging up into existing holdings or checking the momentum leaders for new ideas. If they don't quite fit into my strategy, sometimes they don't miss by much. It can be worthwhile to loosen the criteria a bit to get some new names.

W&T Offshore is up 19.5% since I wrote about it barely a month ago. The super spike in oil suggests this could continue. Since WTI still fits my primary strategy, this isn't exactly a change in process, but it requires sucking it up and paying more if necessary.

3.Go Deep

My next plan would be to go deep. Value, that is. If I can't have a stock I am confident will rise, I want to have some degree of confidence that it won't fall too much. In my case, I usually look at the free cash-flow yield.