Knowledge@Wharton

Try Jim Cramer's Action Alerts PLUS
CLICK HERE NOW

The Economic Stimulus Package: Will It Work, and for Whom?

02/23/08 - 11:13 AM EST

Knowledge @Wharton

Congress and the White House recently settled on an economic stimulus package with unusual speed, pushing the throttle to pull the economy out of a nosedive. Is this just election-year grandstanding, or does economic stimulus really work? And if it can work, what works best?

While some experts argue that priming the economy now is unnecessary, ill-timed or even counter-productive, those who support the concept applaud the design of the recently approved $168 billion package, centered on rebates of $600 to $1,200 for more than 130 million households. "They have moved remarkably quickly, so maybe this time it will, in fact, be well-timed," says Nicholas S. Souleles, finance professor at Wharton. Souleles conducted a study titled, "Household Expenditure and the Income Tax Rebates of 2001," that found a 2001 stimulus package did indeed help the economy recover from recession.

That smaller plan included permanent tax cuts that encouraged consumers to increase their spending, while the current package has only temporary features, he says. But this shortcoming may be offset by today's greater emphasis on getting money to low- and moderate-income people who are especially likely to spend it quickly. "If the new rebate is being more directed towards [financially] constrained households, that ... difference would tend to increase the total spending," he notes. More consumer spending will increase companies' sales, reducing any need for workforce cuts and encouraging growth. At least, that's the theory.

The stimulus should work, suggests Wharton finance professor Jeremy Siegel. But that's what worries him: He thinks the economy is likely to recover later in the year anyway, and that the stimulus package could combine with rising commodity prices to spur inflation. "I do think the economy is going to recover," he says. "The Fed may have to start raising interest rates in the third quarter to offset the stimulus from this package... .This just makes the job of the central bank a little harder."

Housing Bubble vs. Tech Bubble

Offering yet another view, Wharton finance professor Richard Marston thinks today's economic problems are quite different from those of 2001, and likely to be more severe and long-lasting -- and resistant to remedies. The key feature of today's downturn is the collapsed housing bubble, which has a broader effect than the burst tech-stock bubble of 2001, he says.

While the rebates will lead to more spending, Marston notes, the lack of a long-term tax cut will make the stimulus package less effective than the one in 2001. At the same time, the Fed's interest-rate cuts will not work as well because today's credit problems are caused by lenders' fear of risk rather than a shortage of money to lend. Reducing rates will not necessarily reduce that fear. "I think the banking part of this is more problematical this time than it was in 2001 because we're in the middle of a fixed-income crisis -- because people just don't trust each other," he says, adding: "It's very scary, very scary.... I don't see a quick recovery."

It is not yet clear that the U.S. economy fits the technical definition of a recession -- generally seen as two consecutive quarters of economic contraction, plus other criteria -- but there's no doubt it is in trouble. The economy grew just 2.2% in 2007, the lowest level since 1.6% in 2002. In the fourth quarter, it grew at an annual rate of 0.6%, down from 4.9% the quarter before.

Bad economic news has continued this year: On February 15, the government reported that import prices had soared in January at the highest rate since 1983, and that manufacturing was declining. The most recent Reuters/University of Michigan survey showed consumer confidence at its lowest since early 1992.

Previous «
1 2 3 4

Investing A-to-Z

Knowledge@Wharton

Go To Section Home


02/21/08
Ten Financial Lessons for a Richer Life

Take these steps to finding a rewarding life -- in every way.


02/20/08
Inflation Signs Mount, Despite Slow Growth

In minutes of its January meeting the Federal Reserve's fretting about rising prices is trumped by fear of a downturn.


02/14/08
Rebate Checks Could Spark Urge to Splurge

Stimulus package could do more harm than good for consumers.


02/14/08
Eight Sure-Fire Ways to Sock Away $100

Simple steps will put you on the road to serious savings.


02/07/08
10 Free Ways to Boost Your Financial Power

You don't always need to spend money to make money.


01/31/08
Ten Things to Do With Your Tax Rebate

Whether you choose to spend or save the money Congress gives you, you should put it to good use.


01/28/08
Sit Tight and Batten Down the Hatches

Vanguard founder John Bogle says we're in for one of the wildest storms in 30 years. Here's how to weather it.


01/25/08
Seven Extreme Ways to Save

Taking drastic steps can quickly put your finances back in order.


01/18/08
You're Not Saving Enough. Here's Why

Lower-than-expected returns and unexpected expenses could reduce your nest egg.


05/19/08
Cramer on Top Searched Stocks: Yahoo!

Yahoo! is among the most searched stocks on TheStreet.com. Here's what Cramer had to say about the stock recently.


05/17/08
Jim Cramer's Best Blogs

Catch up on his thinking on the hottest topics of the past week.


04/26/08
Coming Week: Make or Break

Investors will have to deal with a Fed meeting and another flood of earnings and economic data.


05/19/08
Top Rocket Stocks: Ensco

Ensco International and Echelon have the potential to move higher in coming days.


04/28/08
Monday's Analysts' Upgrades, Downgrades

See who made what calls.


05/19/08
Telecom Giants See a Savior in Video

The addition of video is helping telecom companies compete against cable and satellite companies.


05/19/08
Contract Expiration Tempers Oil's Rise

The June West Texas Intermediate contract reflects selling pressure ahead of Tuesday's expiration. But stocks in the sector are generally trading higher.


05/19/08
Analysts' Upgrades, Downgrades: Amazon

See who made what calls.


Your Recent Quotes: Quote Up0 | Quote Down0
Dow S&P 500 NASDAQ
Oil*
Gold
10 Yr
0.00%
%
%
%
Data delayed 20 min
Sign up for our FREE newsletters now.

Keep on top of the market and the critical information you need to make more profitable investing decisions.

  • Cramer's Daily Booyah!
  • Before the Bell

Privacy Policy

See All Free Newsletters

Premium Stock Ideas
Access Action Alerts Plus to find out Cramer’s latest picks now!