This account is pending registration confirmation. Please click on the link within the confirmation email previously sent you to complete registration.
Need a new registration confirmation email? Click here
TheStreet Open House

The Downside of Fundamental Indexing

I have written a number of generally positive articles about WisdomTree's dividend-weighted and earnings-weighted exchange-traded funds since they debuted earlier this year.

My only caveat was that they could lag their benchmark indices.

Now that the funds have been trading for a while, it might be a good time to revisit a couple of them to see whether my concern was justified.

The two funds I'll focus on today are the WisdomTree Total Earnings Fund (EXT) and the WisdomTree High-Yielding Equity Fund (DHS).

By definition, these products are a different mix of stocks than their benchmarks; they invest in the same names, but weight them according to fundamental criteria -- in this case, earnings or dividends -- rather than market capitalization.

So both ETFs will underperform at times and outperform at others.

I should note that EXT and DHS each have different benchmarks, and although neither one benchmarks the S&P 500, each benchmark has a correlation of 0.98 or greater to the S&P. So I feel the comparison in the first chart below is valid.

As you can see in the chart, both ETX and DHS have lagged the S&P 500 since the former was launched; DHS has lagged by a wide margin.

Note: Just about every specialized ETF will be vulnerable to something, so when a given fund's something comes into play that fund will lag. This does not make a fund bad or good.

The important thing in selecting ETFs is to identify a potential stumbling block, understand what impact it could have and whether or not, given this stumbling block, you should own it.

EXT is weighted by earnings; the more dollars earned by a company, the larger its weight in the fund. This implies the fund has a value bent.

The lag for EXT has been very slight and I believe can be attributed to this slight tilt to value (as I assess the holdings). For the year to date, large-cap growth stocks have outperformed value by roughly 5%.

The lag for DHS is far more pronounced and also much easier to analyze. DHS, like most broad-based dividend-weighted ETFs, has a very large weight in the financial sector. DHS allocates 35.41% to financials, compared with just 18.66% for the S&P 500.

And as you know, the financials have been pounded by the mortgage crisis and resulting credit crunch.

I believe the abnormally sloped yield curve has played a big part in the current market dislocation and I predicted this might become a problem for the sector and the fund in the first article I wrote about DHS.


Achilles' Heel
DHS has underperformed for most of the year due to its heavy financials weighting
Click here for larger image.
Source:

This issue of vulnerability is not unique to fundamentally weighted ETFs. Market-cap-weighted funds tend to overweight growth stocks, so obviously anything that hurts growth stocks tends to hurt market-cap-weighted funds relative to funds that use other weighting methods. During the tech bubble aftermath, the broader S&P 500 did much worse than large-cap value.


Every Investment Style Has its Day
Value stocks outperformed after the tech bubble burst
Click here for larger image.
Source:

The conclusion has to be that, just as a stock-picker interested in diversification would have stocks from various sectors, cap sizes and volatilities, indexers should understand a fund's weakness before they buy it and should have funds with different kinds of methodologies.

This can include cap weighting, fundamental weighting and equal weighting. They will each lead at some points and lag at others. Diversification means not having too much ride on any one method and hopefully will result in smoother returns.

At the time of publication, Nusbaum had no positions in either EXT or DHS, although positions may change at any time.

Roger Nusbaum is a portfolio manager with Your Source Financial of Phoenix, and the author of Random Roger's Big Picture Blog. Under no circumstances does the information in this column represent a recommendation to buy or sell stocks. Nusbaum appreciates your feedback; click here to send him an email.

Select the service that is right for you!

COMPARE ALL SERVICES
Action Alerts PLUS
Try it NOW

Jim Cramer and Stephanie Link actively manage a real portfolio and reveal their money management tactics while giving advanced notice before every trade.

Product Features:
  • $2.5+ million portfolio
  • Large-cap and dividend focus
  • Intraday trade alerts from Cramer
  • Weekly roundups
TheStreet Quant Ratings
Try it NOW
Only $49.95/yr

Access the tool that DOMINATES the Russell 2000 and the S&P 500.

Product Features:
  • Buy, hold, or sell recommendations for over 4,300 stocks
  • Unlimited research reports on your favorite stocks
  • A custom stock screener
  • Upgrade/downgrade alerts
Stocks Under $10
Try it NOW

David Peltier, uncovers low dollar stocks with extraordinary upside potential that are flying under Wall Street's radar.

Product Features:
  • Model portfolio
  • Stocks trading below $10
  • Intraday trade alerts
  • Weekly roundups
Dividend Stock Advisor
Try it NOW

Jim Cramer's protege, David Peltier, identifies the best of breed dividend stocks that will pay a reliable AND significant income stream.

Product Features:
  • Diversified model portfolio of dividend stocks
  • Alerts when market news affect the portfolio
  • Bi-weekly updates with exact steps to take - BUY, HOLD, SELL
Real Money Pro
Try it NOW

All of Real Money, plus 15 more of Wall Street's sharpest minds delivering actionable trading ideas, a comprehensive look at the market, and fundamental and technical analysis.

Product Features:
  • Real Money + Doug Kass Plus 15 more Wall Street Pros
  • Intraday commentary & news
  • Ultra-actionable trading ideas
Options Profits
Try it NOW

Our options trading pros provide daily market commentary and over 100 monthly option trading ideas and strategies to help you become a well-seasoned trader.

Product Features:
  • 100+ monthly options trading ideas
  • Actionable options commentary & news
  • Real-time trading community
  • Options TV
To begin commenting right away, you can log in below using your Disqus, Facebook, Twitter, OpenID or Yahoo login credentials. Alternatively, you can post a comment as a "guest" just by entering an email address. Your use of the commenting tool is subject to multiple terms of service/use and privacy policies - see here for more details.
Submit an article to us!
DOW 16,795.62 -9.09 -0.05%
S&P 500 1,946.64 +0.48 0.02%
NASDAQ 4,426.1210 +4.0360 0.09%

Brokerage Partners

Rates from Bankrate.com

  • Mortgage
  • Credit Cards
  • Auto

Free Newsletters from TheStreet

My Subscriptions:

After the Bell

Before the Bell

Booyah! Newsletter

Midday Bell

TheStreet Top 10 Stories

Winners & Losers

Register for Newsletters
Top Rated Stocks Top Rated Funds Top Rated ETFs