So what's in a balance sheet?
A company's balance sheet has three main sections:
- Assets: Items of economic value that are owned by a company.
- Liabilities: A company's financial obligations.
- Equity: Sometimes referred to as shareholders' equity, this represents the net accounting value of the company.
How to Spot a Weak Balance SheetLet's start with an example of a truly horrible balance sheet. I have several nominees for this ignominious honor: Six Flags, Level 3 Communications, Sirius Satellite Radio and XM Satellite Radio. (How ironic it is that Sirius and XM, two companies with some of the worst balance sheets, are attempting to merge? Two wrongs won't make a right.) Rather than pick one of those four balance sheets, I will discuss many of the problems that plague all or some of these companies, including:
- Negative or deficit retained earnings
- Negative equity
- Negative net tangible assets
- Low current ratio
Negative or deficit retained earnings:Retained earnings represent the cumulative net income of a company. When a company has a negative retained earnings balance, it says to the world that it has generated accounting losses over a prolonged period of time. Here are the retained earnings, in millions, for Six Flags, Level 3, Sirius and XM -- taken directly from the most recently available quarterly (first quarter of 2007) balance sheets:
- Six Flags: -$1,560.20
- Level 3: -$9,586.00
- Sirius: -$3,978.47
- XM: -$3,620.91
Negative equity:When the deficit in retained earnings surpasses the amount of capital that the company has, this is a red flag that signals that the company is in distress. When a company is in distress, it has two options. Option one is to recapitalize its balance sheet by issuing additional capital (selling common or preferred stock). If that's not possible, then the other option is to file for bankruptcy. Two of the companies I pointed out earlier -- satellite radio twins Sirius and XM -- have negative equity. Those companies chose to merge. Whether or not that merger occurs, I think that in the long run, one of them, both or a combined company may see its destiny in Federal Bankruptcy Court.
Negative net tangible assets:This is caused by an excessive amount of goodwill. Goodwill, or G/W, is the value paid by an acquiring company in excess of the book value of the acquired company. G/W sits on the balance sheet like an ugly mole and has to be amortized (expensed) over a period of time. However, while G/W has an accounting value, it has no economic value. You cannot sell G/W or exchange it for cash. Thus, G/W has to be made up by successfully operating the acquired company. Net tangible assets is equity less G/W. All of the companies I mentioned have negative net tangible assets (below amounts in thousands):
- Six Flags: - $848,776
- Level 3: - $803,000
- Sirius: - $505,564
- XM: - $650,089
Low current ratio:The current ratio is derived by dividing a balance sheet's "current assets" amount by its "current liabilities" amount. This ratio represents the ability of the company to meet its short-term obligations, such as accounts payables and current portion of long-term debt, from readily available sources, such as cash, short-term investments, accounts receivable and inventory. A high current ratio indicates a liquid company. A low ratio indicates that the company will have problems meeting its short-term obligations, and it could spell more-significant problems. Look for companies with current ratios of at least 1.00 -- but to be on the safe side, add some room for comfort and look for a slightly higher ratio. Sirius, XM and Six Flags all have low current ratios (see below), and this is not a good sign. And even though Level 3 has a current ratio of 1.44, it is saddled with a great deal of long-term debt, which is another red flag. To recap, total current assets divided by total current liabilities equals current ratio:
- Six Flags: $155,308 / $496,294 = 0.31
- Level 3: $1,504,000 / $1,043,000 = 1.44
- Sirius: $479,802 / $750,702 = 0.63
- XM: $432,658 / $694,322 = 0.62
How to Spot a Strong Balance SheetIt would be easy to state that a strong balance sheet has none of the problems of a weak balance sheet, but that is not necessarily the case. There is nothing wrong with having G/W, and G/W appears on some fantastic balance sheets. It is the magnitude of G/W in relation to the company's overall balance sheet that separates the financially strong companies from the financially weak ones. Certainly, a high current ratio would be a welcome sign of a good balance sheet. Again, you need to be careful to only use the current ratio as a starting point. So what are some of the other standout metrics of a good balance sheet? Here are a few key indicators of strength:
- Cash and short-term investments
- Low or zero long-term debt
- Undervalued assets
Cash and short-term investments:Nothing signals a strong company more than piles of cash and short-term investments (such as CDs or T-bills). This will not only provide coverage for the payment of current liabilities, but it will also give a company the ability to return value to shareholders. How? Companies can return the cash to shareholders through stock repurchases and dividends.
Low or zero long-term debt:We all live our lives in the hope of not having to pay off our home mortgage. Companies are no different. Long-term debt is money that companies borrowed that needs to be paid back in more than one year and could be due in as much as 30 years. Companies with balance sheets that are not saddled with debt are among my favorite kind to invest in. For the reasons that I mentioned above, some of my favorite balance sheets belong to Apple, Google and Microsoft:
|Recent Quarterly Balance Sheet Data
(Q1-2007, amounts in millions of US dollars)
|Source: TheStreet.com Quotes Section
*Displayed as "Marketable Securities"
Undervalued assets:This metric of strength is a little more difficult to spot. In fact, undervalued assets might not be recognized at all unless you do some research into the company itself. According to accounting rules, assets are held at cost less accumulated depreciation. Thus, there may be some value over and above the "book value" of certain assets. Here is a look at the sources of two typically undervalued assets:
Real estate:What happens if a company has a piece of prime property, such as Macy's block-long Herald Square store in midtown Manhattan? The balance sheet does not reflect the current value of such an asset. If you dig a little deeper into what a company owns, sometimes you can find a real diamond in the rough. For example, real estate was one of the motivating forces behind Eddie Lampert's acquisition of Kmart debt in bankruptcy and subsequent acquisition of Sears.
Intangible assets:"Intangibles" represent certain nonphysical intellectual property and rights that a company might own. These assets usually have no recurring cost other than the initial development and legal fees incurred to create the items. However, the potential for monetizing those intangible assets is enormous. Examples of intangible assets would be a brand name such as Coke or a logo such as the Ralph Lauren polo horse. Again, Sears offers some intriguing hidden value with brand names such as Craftsman (tools), Kenmore (appliances) and DieHard (auto batteries). As a result, Sears' balance sheet is another one of my favorites.
A 'Work-in-Progress' Balance SheetI am very focused on companies with strong balance sheets, but I also look for companies that are working hard to improve their financial status. When investing, you never want to sacrifice the future to benefit short-term appearances. Management's focus on changing the financial condition of a company will pay long-term benefits to shareholders (see "
- Review the balance sheets for your stock investments. Determine if you are invested in a company with a strong, weak or work-in-progress balance sheet.
- Look for companies you don't currently own, by scanning for high current ratios, large levels of cash and low levels of debt. Then do some fundamental research on your results. This could identify new investment opportunities.
- Apply balance sheet management to your own financial situation.