The Oil Drubbing's Over

No positions

Raising Doubts on Vista

1/19/2007 8:02 AM EST

If you like everyone's new favorite stock, Microsoft(MSFT Quote), I suggest you read Walter Mossberg's review of Windows Vista in yesterday's Wall Street Journal.

Vista, as most are aware, is coming to the consumer market on Jan. 30; it replaces Windows XP.

Mossberg makes a number of points including:

• Vista is pretty -- cool icons, translucent borders, good security features, universal search built in and a display of a preview of what is contained in taskbar items and folders.
• Vista does not represent a radical overhaul, however. Most of its new features have been available in Apple's Mac OS X (which was introduced nearly six years ago!). Apple's original system was upgraded in 2005 and its newest version of OS X (Leopard) is due in three months.
• To get the full benefit of Vista (especially the Aero interface) one needs a powerful and (most likely) a new computer. "The vast majority of existing Windows PCs won't be able to use all of Vista's features without major hardware upgrades. They will be able to run only a stripped-down version, and even then it may run very slowly." It will be expensive for the consumer to benefit totally from MSFT's new product as Vista will revert to very basic features if one's computer is too slow. "For most users who want Vista, I strongly recommend buying a new PC with the new operating system preloaded. I wouldn't even consider trying to upgrade a computer older than 18 months, and even some of them may be unsuitable candidates."
• Vista requires constant updating of security programs; "it's annoying and burdensome." In general, Vista requires frequent management of the computer.
• The consumer versions of Vista are Home Premium and Home Basic, which does not include the new Aero interface.

Short Microsoft