ETF Tuesday

Try Jim Cramer's Action Alerts PLUS
CLICK HERE NOW

New Financial ETF Historically Strong

10/17/06 - 09:31 AM EDT

Roger Nusbaum

The never-ending quest for better mousetraps continues as PowerShares nine sector ETFs that apply Robert Arnott's fundamental indexing methodology of weighting for book value, income, sales and dividends.

This article will focus on the PowerShares FTSE RAFI Financials Sector Portfolio PRFF.

In the Powershares literature, the fund compares itself and its returns to the iShares Dow Jones Financial Sector ETF IYF and the S&P Financial Sector SPDR XLF.

All three look to be very similar. They all have large positions in the same mega-cap names; Citigroup C, Bank of America BAC, JPMorgan Chase JPM and Wells Fargo WFC.

The three funds also have similar weightings in capital-markets names and REITs and tilt toward value over growth.

So on the surface, there's not much difference. But as is the case with most new ETFs, the back test is the compelling question when considering the PRFF.

In this chart, the back test for PRFF is the leader in orange, the S&P Financial Index in brown and the Dow Jones Financial Index in blue. That the PowerShares back test looks so strong is not a shock for two reasons.

From a cynical standpoint, if the results of a back test were horrible, it is reasonable to believe there would be no fund launched.

From a more fundamental standpoint, it's not surprising a strategy that generally favors value over growth would show better returns in a sector that is more of a value-oriented part of the market.


PowerShares FTSE RAFI Financials Sector Portfolio Back Test

One contributing factor to PRFF's outperformance might be the smaller weighting in Citigroup.

Over the past five years, Citigroup has lagged both IYF and XLF by a noticeable amount. Citigroup is weighted at 7.86% in IYF, 9.8% in XLF, but only 4.26% in PRFF.

Citigroup, as a mega-cap, has been the wrong part of the market, and like most mega-caps, it has lagged its sector. There is no guarantee this will persist, and in fact, it is a reasonable that mega-caps will lead the market again. But the exact timing can only be guessed.

What makes analyzing the PRFF's better returns difficult is being able to access the history of portfolio changes as applied to the back test. I was not able to find this information on either the PowerShares or Research Affiliates Web sites. I chose not to inquire directly because in writing this article, I want to take the same tact that a do-it-yourself investor would be able to take in trying to decide whether to buy this fund.

And that is the question: Should this fund be bought?

I do not believe in speculating on a sector that you believe will do well. For me, the context is if you build a portfolio and access sectors by using sector funds, is PRFF the best way to own the financial sector? I am not sure we can know yet, because the fund is so new and all we have to go on is back testing. I do believe in the concept implemented by Arnott and applied to this fund, and I would not be the least bit surprised to see this fund continue to beat its competition, IYF and XLF.


Citigroup (C) Daily

But for my clients that do own IYF, I would want to see more of a real-world track record (as opposed to just relying on the back test) before making a switch.

A last point would be that even if PRFF does turn out to be a better mousetrap, at some point in the future something else may come along that is better still. Anyone relying on investment products for their portfolio need to stay on top of the new products coming to market. Despite what seems like a lot of new ETFs lately, there will continue to be innovation in new products like PRFF.




At the time of publication, Nusbaum was long Bank of America and IYF as client holdings, although positions may change at any time.

Roger Nusbaum is a portfolio manager with Your Source Financial of Phoenix, Ariz., and the author of Random Roger's Big Picture Blog. Under no circumstances does the information in this column represent a recommendation to buy or sell stocks. Nusbaum appreciates your feedback; click here to send him an email.


Previous Story

Too Many ETFs?

Life & Money

ETF Tuesday

Go To Section Home


10/11/06
ETFs Pick Up $4 Billion

That's a decrease from August's $10 billion in new assets.


10/10/06
Too Many ETFs?

With new launches at a blistering rate, some fret about the product's purpose.


10/04/06
Ask TheStreet: So Many ETFs

A little research can go a long way toward choosing a fund that's best for you.


10/03/06
New ETF Hits Gold in Materials Sector

This iShares offering takes a more diversified approach than earlier instruments.


09/26/06
This ETF Hogs Yield

A new Claymore fund aims to double the yield of the existing dividend ETFs.


05/19/08
Cramer on Top Searched Stocks: Yahoo!

Yahoo! is among the most searched stocks on TheStreet.com. Here's what Cramer had to say about the stock recently.


05/17/08
Jim Cramer's Best Blogs

Catch up on his thinking on the hottest topics of the past week.


04/26/08
Coming Week: Make or Break

Investors will have to deal with a Fed meeting and another flood of earnings and economic data.


05/19/08
Top Rocket Stocks: Ensco

Ensco International and Echelon have the potential to move higher in coming days.


04/28/08
Monday's Analysts' Upgrades, Downgrades

See who made what calls.


05/19/08
Telecom Giants See a Savior in Video

The addition of video is helping telecom companies compete against cable and satellite companies.


05/19/08
Contract Expiration Tempers Oil's Rise

The June West Texas Intermediate contract reflects selling pressure ahead of Tuesday's expiration. But stocks in the sector are generally trading higher.


05/19/08
Analysts' Upgrades, Downgrades: Amazon

See who made what calls.


Your Recent Quotes: Quote Up0 | Quote Down0
Dow S&P 500 NASDAQ
Oil*
Gold
10 Yr
0.00%
%
%
%
Data delayed 20 min
Sign up for our FREE newsletters now.

Keep on top of the market and the critical information you need to make more profitable investing decisions.

  • Cramer's Daily Booyah!
  • Before the Bell

Privacy Policy

See All Free Newsletters

Premium Stock Ideas