This column was originally published on RealMoney on Sept. 7 at 10:22 a.m. EST. It's being republished as a bonus for TheStreet.com readers.
The Internet bubble gets all the attention, but the telecom blowup was just as painful and has left investors in the sector wary of re-entry. However, in order to maintain a diversified portfolio, there should be some exposure to the telecom sector.
These days, telecom has about a 3% weight in the
. Over the last few years, the sector has lagged the broader market badly and its weight in the SPX is much lower than in the past. Often when a sector's weight deviates from the historical norm, it eventually will revert back to it. This, along with how much the sector is disliked, may give telecom shares a chance to outperform.
There are three telecom-sector ETFs: two domestic --
iShares Dow Jones U.S. Telecom Fund
Vanguard Telecom Services VIPERs
-- and one global, the
iShares S&P Global Telecom Sector Index Fund
For domestic telecom exposure, VOX looks to be the best choice. Its portfolio is the most diversified, with 64% of the fund in its top 10 holdings, compared with almost 80% for IYZ. One of the primary benefits of ETFs is that they avoid risks related to the performance of individual stocks. An ETF with too much concentration in the top 10 holdings can lead to more volatility.
Another factor in VOX's favor is its high dividend yield of 2.37%, compared with 1.30% for IYZ and 1.8% for the S&P 500.
Lastly, VOX is cheaper. Its fees amount to only 25 basis points, while IYZ charges 60 basis points. Fees are not necessarily the be-all and end-all in choosing an ETF, but they matter, and because VOX looks like it wins on other fronts, the cheaper fees are a nice extra.
Balance In Everything
Where VOX comes up short is that it has no foreign exposure. I maintain about a 30% weighting in foreign stocks for most clients because I am a big believer in the benefits of foreign diversification as a general principle. I also believe we may be facing a period of below-average returns for U.S. markets over the next few years.
There is value in blending VOX with IXP, a global sector ETF, to gain foreign exposure. The fund is 54% committed to the U.S. and the U.K., and then is spread out between Spain, Japan, France, Germany, Italy, Canada and Australia.
IXP has 66% of its funds invested in foreign telecom stocks and also has a degree of emerging-market exposure -- 6.5% or 7%, depending on whether you believe Greece belongs in that category. Despite the modest allocation to emerging markets, IXP has almost no correlation to emerging-market funds.
|The IXP Alternative
This global ETF pairs well with VOX
|Source: Your Source Financial
As an example of how to implement a VOX/IXP combo, let's say an investor wants to allocate $30,000 to the telecom sector for a diversified portfolio. This investor also wants to have a 25% weighting in foreign stocks. He could sink $19,000 into VOX and $11,000 into IXP. Because 33% of IXP's holdings are in domestic stocks, this combo creates the 75%-25% blend in the sector that the investor is seeking.
One thing about some foreign countries, and investing in them, is they have fewer moving parts than American firms. Owning the phone company can sometimes be a good proxy for an entire country. This can make the telecom sector particularly appealing for foreign investing.
Both strategies have a downside or two. VOX has 20% in
(VZ - Get Report)
, 14% in
and 6.5% in
. IXP weights the three at 8.75%, 7.5% and 4.7%, respectively. All three have been high-yielding laggards. Despite this lag, both VOX and IXP have done reasonably well. At some point, these three Bells will probably provide leadership in the sector, and perhaps the market. If and when that happens, both VOX and IXP could take a serious move up.
A Closed-End Around Emerging Markets
Telecom shares also can offer easy entry into emerging markets. Most exotic investment destinations have easily accessible stocks like Hungary's
Compania de Telecommunicaciones de Chile S.A.
. While owning a single stock, like the Hungarian Bell, may not fit your risk profile, there is a closed-end fund that might: the
Emerging Markets Telecommunications Fund
ETF provides investors with emerging-market exposure
|Source: Your Source Financial