Futures Shock

Financial Gravity and the Yield Curve

 

Flat Curve Winners and Losers

Let's return to an analytic technique first introduced here in February and used several times since, that of measuring the relative impact of a market factor on industry groups.

Negative numbers in the table below indicate groups benefiting from or at least not hurt by the flatter yield curve, while positive numbers indicate groups hurt by the flatter curve. The groups with statistically significant relationships (90% confidence interval) against the large-cap S&P 500, the mid-cap S&P 400 and the small-cap S&P 600 are displayed.

The list of victims is pretty clear across market capitalization levels. Utilities, REITs, oil-related groups, pharmaceuticals and financial firms, particularly thrifts and mortgages, should underperform by virtue of the flattening curve. Relative winners are in the technology sector, especially semiconductors and software, and in electrical goods manufacturing.

This list of winners and losers relative to the forward rate ratio is not significantly different from the one posted in May. As the forward rate ratio between two and 10 years has declined from 1.02818 to 1.00578 during the interim, let's see how effective the relative performance signals were.

Relative Industry Group Betas to Forward Rate
S&P 500 S&P 400 S&P 600
Group Beta Group Beta Group Beta
IT CONS&SERV (1.278) COMP&PERPH (1.091) MARINE (1.208)
ELEC MANU SRVC (0.938) AIRLINES (1.077) SYS SFW (1.144)
DEPT STORES (0.834) SEMICONDUCTORS (1.021) ENVR SRVCS (0.893)
MCYCL MANF (0.819) IT CNSLTNG (0.937) TRDNG COMP (0.761)
COMP&ELECT (0.723) DIV COM SV (0.909) DATA PRCS & OTS (0.749)
APPLIC SFTW (0.697) TRUCKING (0.871) SEMICONDUCTOR (0.694)
SEMICONDUCTORS (0.691) OFFCE SERV (0.832) ADVERTISING (0.654)
COMMERCIAL P (0.572) HLTHCR FAC (0.620) LEISURE PROD (0.644)
RAILROADS (0.559) TECH DIST (0.570) TRUCKING (0.579)
DIV COMM SER (0.527) ELE CMP&EQ (0.503) SPEC STRS (0.482)
DRUG RETAIL (0.513) APPRL & ACCESS (0.478)
INDUST GASES (0.469) COMP & EQUIP (0.395)
SYSTEMS SFTW (0.430) APPL SFW (0.372)
DATA PRCS & OTS (0.428)
ELEC COM&EQU (0.362)
PHARM 0.356 MLTIUTIL 0.345 GAS UTIL 0.350
DIV BANKS 0.433 ELEC UTIL 0.393 ELEC UTIL 0.378
GAS UTIL 0.461 TRFT/MRTG FINCE 0.400 REITS 0.507
REAL EST INV 0.598 PRP&CAS INS 0.404 THFT & MRTG FIN 0.635
THFTS & MRTGE 0.721 PAPER PRDCT 0.608 HOMEBUILDING 0.693
FOREST PROD 0.728 LEISURE FC 0.649 INSUR BRKG 0.811
OIL & GAS EQU 0.782 REITS 0.678 OIL&GAS EXPL 0.821
SPECIALIZED FIN 0.856 PHARMCTCLS 0.820 OIL&GAS 0.919
OIL&GAS EXPX 0.949 OIL&G STR&TRD 0.849 PAPER 0.942
OIL&GAS DRIL 1.375 OIL&G EQUI 0.853 MOV & ENTR 1.022
GOLD 2.947 MLTISECTOR 0.899 HSHLD PROD 1.091
SOFTDRNKS 0.912 OIL&GAS REF 1.102
OIL&G EXPL 1.062 OIL&GAS PROD 1.252
Source: Bloomberg

For this exercise, we will combine all of the S&P indices into the S&P 1500 Supercomposite. The total return of each industry group over the six months since May will be multiplied by the group's weight in the Supercomposite. Only a handful of groups had capitalization-adjusted returns of less than a -.05% contribution to the index's total return of 6.86% over this period. Three of these underperformers -- pharmaceuticals, packaged foods and thrifts and mortgages -- were expected to be affected negatively by the flatter yield curve, and they were. Pharmaceuticals in fact had the worst total return times capitalization product of any group: -0.59%.

If we move outside of the zone of underperformance, the picture starts to change. The chart below depicts the groups' whose capitalization-weighted total returns exceeded 0.05%. They are color-coded as black for basic materials, violet for utilities, turquoise for information technology, green for financials and red for energy. All others are colored white.

Capitalization-Weighted Six-Month Total Return
Source: Bloomberg

We expected the technology groups to slough off higher interest rates, a stronger dollar and a flatter yield curve -- and this certainly was true for computer hardware, communications equipment, system software, data processing and outsourcing, and semiconductors.

But what about the oil-related groups? These were expected to be affected negatively by the above-named factors, and yet their performance topped the charts. Here the answer is obvious: The financial factors affecting the oil-related issues negatively simply were overwhelmed by the unprecedented gains in crude oil, natural gas and refinery margins. Other executives might kill to have profits gaudy enough to be dragged up to Capitol Hill for a tongue-lashing.

The performance of the financial issues is fascinating. It was taken as gospel for years that this sector was one giant "carry trade" whose profits were generated from borrowing at the short end of the curve and ending at the long end of the curve. But these are not your father's financials; they make money more on trading, fees, prime brokerage and other services unrelated to the yield curve. Who knows how strong their performance would have been in the absence of the recent flattening of the curve?

Newton had one last relationship figured out: Force equals mass times acceleration. The large mass of the combined financial and energy sectors is being affected by an accelerating flattening trend both in the U.S. and in the eurozone. That force is being resisted and indeed pushed back by profit growth elsewhere and by increased risk acceptance. But it is there, pushing toward us. Just because it hasn't ruined anything yet doesn't mean it's incapable of doing so.

>To order reprints of this article, click here: Reprints

Howard L. Simons is president of Simons Research, a strategist for Bianco Research, a trading consultant and the author of The Dynamic Option Selection System. Under no circumstances does the information in this column represent a recommendation to buy or sell securities. While Simons cannot provide investment advice or recommendations, he appreciates your feedback; click here to send him an email.

TheStreet.com has a revenue-sharing relationship with Amazon.com under which it receives a portion of the revenue from Amazon purchases by customers directed there from TheStreet.com.

TheStreet Premium Services

Jim Cramer
Jim Cramer's Action Alerts PLUS:
Trade right alongside a Wall Street pro — enjoy access to his Charitable Trust portfolio and be sent trade alerts BEFORE he makes a move. Learn More
OptionsProfits
OptionsProfits:
Get 50+ trade ideas a week from the industry's top options experts. Plus — exclusive commentary on market trends and essential trading tools. Learn More
Real Money
Real Money:
Our team of professional Wall Street Pros — including Jim Cramer, Doug Kass, and Nicholas Vardy — delivers intelligent analysis, timely trade ideas, and colorful commentary. Learn More
Stocks Under $10
Stocks Under $10:
Break into the market with small- and mid-cap stocks... all $10 or less! David Peltier tells you exactly which low-priced stocks he's buying and selling. Learn More
To begin commenting right away, you can log in below using your Disqus, Facebook, Twitter, OpenID or Yahoo login credentials. Alternatively, you can post a comment as a "guest" just by entering an email address. Your use of the commenting tool is subject to multiple terms of service/use and privacy policies - see here for more details.
blog comments powered by Disqus
Dow Jones S&P 500 NASDAQ 10-Year Note
12,393.45 1,310.33 2,827.34 15.81
Oil *
101.78
DOWN
26.41
DOWN
2.99
DOWN
10.02
DOWN
0.44
10 Yr
1.58%
SPDR Gold
151.62
-0.21%
-0.23%
-0.35%
-2.71%
Data delayed 20 minutes

Top Stories and Tools

Articles From

After the Bell

Before the Bell

Booyah! Newsletter

Midday Bell

TheStreet Top 10 Stories

Winners & Losers

We respect your privacy.
Podcasts

Connect with TheStreet