Qwest-Enron Deal Puts Swaps Back in Spotlight
Like swapaholics at last call, Qwest (Q) and Enron (ENRNQ) bellied up to the bandwidth bar last fall for one last deal before the lights came on and the music stopped.
Eager Beavers
But industry insiders and analysts familiar with these transactions say the deal underscores the eagerness of some cash-strapped telcos to meet investor expectations in an industry awash in surplus capacity. More importantly, it raises new questions about the current market values of all telecom assets, from network capacity to next-generation optical gear. "Nearly all the trades between carriers by 2001, after the networks were all completed, were questionable," says Friedman Billings Ramsey analyst Susan Kalla, who has no rating on Qwest. Friedman has no underwriting ties to Qwest. "If all the service providers were forced to write down the assets to what they are really worth today, it would cause the biggest destruction of shareholder equity you've ever seen," says John Abraham, former director of global wholesale markets for Enron Broadband and now a telecom consultant with Novus Partners in Dallas. With rival phone companies filling the void where real customers should have been, the revenues were unsustainable. As we've seen, several of the biggest IRU (indefeasible rights of use) wheelers and dealers, like Global Crossing, Enron, 360networks and ICG, have collapsed. The Justice Department and the Securities and Exchange Commission are investigating the capacity sales of failed broadband network operator Global Crossing and of a number of telcos, including Qwest, which played a role in the deals. To be sure, capacity sales themselves aren't illegal. But the accounting methods that some swappers have used have drawn criticism from investors. Typically, an IRU is a long-term lease of capacity. But instead of spreading the revenue from that lease over the length of the contract, many companies booked it all at once as a one-time sale. Likewise, companies that purchased capacity typically characterized the deal as an investment in property and assets, not as a traditional expense. So in these tit-for-tat deals, a company could use IRUs to enhance both the top line and the bottom line of their financial statement.'Good Deal'
According to the court documents, Enron Broadband, the wholesale network-capacity trading arm of the failed Enron Corp., paid Qwest $112 million in their $195 million agreement to buy live optical network capacity. In exchange, Qwest paid Enron $112 million of a $308 million contract for a stretch of idle unequipped cable, known as dark fiber, between Salt Lake City and New Orleans. Qwest confirms cash changed hands. Another former Enron Broadband manager who was familiar with the Qwest deal defended the transaction. "At the time, we were trying to realign ourselves, and Qwest would have been a strong strategic relationship," the manager says. "I think it would have been a good deal had we not gone bankrupt." Despite all the market value that's melted away in companies such as Qwest and WorldCom (WCOM) amid liquidity concerns and slipping credit quality, there still may be a deeper fall before the true values are laid bare. "Everyone knows what this stuff is really worth," says former Enron executive Abraham, referring to the values attached to many of these transactions. "But no one has the guts to say: 'The emperor has no clothes.' ">To order reprints of this article, click here: ReprintsTheStreet Premium Services For Personal Service: 877-471-2967
Jim Cramer's Action Alerts PLUS:
Trade right alongside a Wall Street pro — enjoy access to his Charitable Trust portfolio and be sent trade alerts BEFORE he makes a move. Learn MoreETF Profits:
Get money-making ideas from the hottest investment vehicle on the planet. Our experts show you how to play various ETF sectors to help pump-up your portfolio. Learn MoreOptionsProfits:
Get 50+ trade ideas a week from the industry's top options experts. Plus — exclusive commentary on market trends and essential trading tools. Learn MoreReal Money:
Our team of professional Wall Street Pros — including Jim Cramer, Doug Kass, and Nicholas Vardy — delivers intelligent analysis, timely trade ideas, and colorful commentary. Learn MoreStocks Under $10:
Break into the market with small- and mid-cap stocks... all $10 or less! David Peltier tells you exactly which low-priced stocks he's buying and selling. Learn MoreTo begin commenting right away, you can log in below using your Disqus, Facebook, Twitter, OpenID or Yahoo login credentials. Alternatively, you can post a comment as a "guest" just by entering an email address. Your use of the commenting tool is subject to multiple terms of service/use and privacy policies - see here for more details.
blog comments powered by Disqus
| Dow Jones | S&P 500 | NASDAQ | 10-Year Note | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12,801.23 | 1,342.64 | 2,903.88 | 19.69 |
Oil *
117.67
|
|
DOWN
89.23 |
DOWN
9.31 |
DOWN
23.35 |
DOWN
0.78 |
10 Yr
1.97%
SPDR Gold
167.14
|
|
-0.69%
|
-0.69%
|
-0.80%
|
-3.81%
|
Data delayed 20 minutes |

Connect with TheStreet