Try Jim Cramer's Action Alerts PLUS
CLICK HERE NOW
The Finance Professor

How to Invest in Food Stocks: Restaurants

Scott Rothbort

03/07/08 - 05:32 PM EST
It is only fitting that we end our journey along the food investment chain with a discussion of my favorite link, the restaurant sector (see "A Checklist for Profiting from Retail, Restaurant Stocks" and "Three Ways to Score With Retail, Restaurant Stocks").

To get up to speed on the food investment chain, check out "How to Invest in Food Stocks" and "How to Invest in Food Stocks: The 'Middleman' Plays."

This series of lessons concludes with a look at some restaurant specifics that investors should be cognizant of before making an investment, by highlighting challenges in the current agricultural and economic environment.

The Source

Restaurants will prepare fresh meals from a variety of food sources. Some will cook meals from basic products (like meat, chicken and pasta) which they purchase from suppliers and wholesalers. These companies will make everything from hamburger patties to frozen cod filets to those chicken fingers that kids love to eat.

Many restaurants will just purchase and serve prepared foods or beverages from those same food wholesalers or beverage bottlers covered in "How to Invest in Food Stocks: The 'Middleman' Plays," or from local establishments, such as bakers and dairies.

Several restaurant chains will provide their individual locations with their own prepared products or basic ingredients. As an example, Domino's Pizza DPZ not only owns and franchises their restaurants, but Domino's also distributes the critical cheese and other products to its franchisees.

Finally, restaurants will buy paper goods, cups, glasses and restaurant supplies from a variety of vendors.

Some of the nation's largest food wholesalers that distribute products to restaurants are:

Food Wholesalers and Distributors
Company Ticker Symbol Closing Share Price
on 3/4/2008
2007
EPS (Earnings Per Share)
2008
Estimated EPS
Dean Foods DF 21.43 1.20 1.27
Tyson Foods TSN 14.92 0.74 0.26
Source: Yahoo! Finance

Price Points

As agricultural prices have soared, those costs are being pushed throughout the food chain. How do restaurants handle these inflationary pressures? There are a few ways in which this is accomplished: price hikes, portion reduction and hedging.

Raising prices. This is very simple: As a restaurant owner, just push cost prices onto your customers. Here's the catch, it's not always that easy.

Raising a steak dinner from $19.95 to $22.95 might be easier than increasing the price of a cheeseburger from $1.99 to $2.29. It all depends on the demographic that you serve and the category of restaurant that the company operates in (see below).

Most restaurants manage off of an average ticket price. Thus for the higher ticket restaurants passing the cost can be more direct because it will get lost in the already high average check price, as those diners will be less "price sensitive." For the lower-priced restaurants, the business makes it up in extras or side dishes. For example, instead of pushing up the price of a cheeseburger 20 cents -- which would immediately catch the customers' eye -- the price costs are piled into the price of a beverage or fries or the combination meal where the price increase is less evident and "elastic." You can extend this concept to beer and hard liquor, which are always great places to embed price increases (see "How to Be So Money at the Bars" on TheStreet.com TV).

Cutting down on portion sizes. Instead of putting 10 ounces of chicken strips into a salad, a restaurant will place 9 ounces and leave the menu price unchanged. Perhaps they will use less pasta in a side dish. This is easier achieved at the higher-priced restaurants than the lower-priced ones because the former tend to serve larger and more complex dishes.

Contracting for commodities. More and more, restaurants are risk-managing their commodity costs by locking in to long-term contracts with suppliers or hedging with many of the same commodity futures futures-contract that investors and speculators speculator will engage in, such as beef, pork bellies, soy beans and sugar (to name a few).

Spectrum of Service and Quality

The restaurant sector is divided into three main categories and offers a wide variety of investment opportunities -- from quick service to premium dining.

Quick Service Restaurants (QSRs). Known to many people as "fast food" restaurants, QSRs have the following characteristics:

  • Diners order at a counter from a menu on an overhead menu board. Many also have drive-through service.
  • Diners bus their own food trays from the service counter to unassigned seating.
  • Menu items are relatively "cheap," with many QSRs providing value or combination meal pricing.
  • Beverages are limited to nonalcoholic varieties.
  • The most popular QSRs are:

    Quality Service Restaurants (QSRs)
    Company Ticker Symbol Closing Share Price
    on 3/4/2008
    2007
    EPS (Earnings Per Share)
    2008
    Estimated EPS
    McDonald's MCD 53.63 2.89 3.18
    Burger King BKC 26.35 1.11 1.31
    Yum Brands YUM 35.02 1.68 1.86
    Wendy's WEN 23.91 1.20 1.32
    Domino's Pizza DPZ 13.34 1.03 1.03
    Starbucks SBUX 17.90 0.87 0.97
    Chipotle Mexican Grill CMG 96.52 2.13 2.67
    Panera Bread PNRA 36.85 1.82 2.02
    Tim Horton's THI 34.67 1.34 1.65
    Source: Yahoo! Finance

    Casual Dining Restaurants (CDRs). These establishments are known for their family-friendly menus and atmosphere. CDRs have the following characteristics:

  • Diners are serviced at assigned tables.
  • The ambience is family-themed and friendly.
  • Menus are varied and more comprehensive than that of QSRs.
  • Many CDRs have a central theme or common food selection (like Asian, Mexican, Italian, steak or seafood).
  • Menu prices are moderate but vary amongst QSRs and amongst menu items.
  • Alcoholic beverages are also served.
  • The most popular QSR chains are:

    Casual Dining Restaurants (CDRs)
    Company Ticker Symbol Price
    3/4/2008
    2007
    EPS
    2008
    Est. EPS
    Darden DRI 31.14 2.53 2.72
    Brinker International EAT 18.05 1.76 1.42
    Ruby Tuesday RT 6.80 1.66 0.45
    IHOP IHP 45.21 2.51 2.46
    McCormick & Schmicks MSSR 10.89 0.91 0.69
    Cheescake Factory CAKE 20.59 1.03 1.15
    PF Chang's China Bistro PFCB 27.67 1.36 1.35
    Buffalo Wild Wings BWLD 22.08 1.10 1.33
    Red Robin Gourmet RRGB 34.02 1.98 2.14
    Source: Yahoo! Finance

    Premium Dining Restaurants (PDRs). These restaurants are like CDRs with some subtle differences:

  • Food quality and menu variety is of higher quality. The menus tend to be oriented toward premium cuts of beef and steak and high-end seafood.
  • More luxurious ambience.
  • Attract adult or business diners.
  • The most popular PDR chains are:

    Premium Dining Restaurants (PDRs)
    Company SYMBOL Price
    3/4/2008
    2007
    EPS
    2008
    Est. EPS
    Ruth's Chris RUTH 7.04 0.78 0.68
    Morton's MRT 7.86 0.75 0.74
    Source: Yahoo! Finance

    The companies listed here are far from exhaustive and I suggest you do some homework to spot your own investment opportunities in the restaurant sector.

    With rising ingredient costs and a slowing domestic economic climate, we are currently in a very difficult environment for investing in restaurants. However, I believe that late this spring or early this summer excellent value value-stock investment opportunities will begin to materialize. This window of opportunity should give you ample time to do more research and identify some restaurant stocks to be placed on your investment menu.

    Currently, the only restaurant that I own is McDonald's MCD. McDonald's has been able to weather the domestic slowdown by attracting more diners with expanded hours of operation, creative menu additions and the introduction of premium coffee -- to the detriment of the pricey Starbucks SBUX. In addition, McDonald's is growing overseas, particularly in China.