Energy Funds Rally As Crude Ends Slide
Kevin Baker
08/31/07 - 04:45 PM EDT
Other than a few Mexican state-owned offshore platforms, Hurricane Dean failed to knock out Gulf of Mexico oil drilling operations.
However, we are not out of the woods yet. The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration confirmed earlier this month that it still places the chance of an above-normal 2007 Atlantic hurricane season at 85%.
So oil traders, with one eye on the most recent tropical disturbance, arrested the late-July/early August decline in the price of crude oil. Bullish petroleum inventory figures also contributed to the move.
The top performing fund this week, the
United States Oil Fund LP (USO Quote), rose 5.41%, buying futures contracts to approximate the performance of the spot price of crude oil. That's a pretty good performance for this exchange-traded fund when you consider that the spot price of West Texas Intermediate crude oil added just 4.83% over the same period.
In second place, the
(TYN Quote)Tortoise North American Energy Corp. returned 3.99% over the five trading days.
The fund's portfolio of Canadian royalty and income trusts RITs and U.S. master limited partnerships, or MLPs, is allocated to 37.9% crude/refined product pipelines, 21.0% natural gas gathering and processing, 17.5% natural gas and liquefied natural gas pipelines, 8.0% oil and gas royalty trusts and 5.6% electric generation.
The largest holdings include:
Kinder Morgan Management (KMR Quote), at 8.84% of assets; Keyera Facilities Income Fund, at 8.35%;
Enbridge Energy Management (EEQ Quote), at 7.80%; and Pembina Pipeline Income Fund, at 7.32%.
A closed-end fund, the
(KYE Quote)Kayne Anderson Energy Total Return Fund (KYE), tops our list of retreating funds this week, shedding 6.53%. This fund also invests in RITs and MLPs, with the largest holdings being Kinder Morgan Management, at 11.0% of total investments;
Plains All American Pipeline LP (PAA Quote), at 6.8%;
Enterprise Products Partners LP (EPD Quote), at 3.5%; and Enbridge Energy Management, at 2.6%.
Second from the bottom was the
Claymore MACROShares Oil Down(DCR Quote), which fell 4.86%, successfully tracking the inverse performance of the price of crude. This fund takes the opposite side of the market as the third
best performer, the
Claymore MACROshares Oil Up Tradable Trust (UCR Quote), which lagged its benchmark with a return of just 3.34%.
Best Performing Energy Funds Total return for the week ended Aug. 30. |
| Fund |
Ticker |
Rating |
Fund Type |
1 Week Total Return |
| United States Oil Fund LP |
USO |
E |
ETF |
5.41% |
| Tortoise North American Energy Corp |
TYN |
B+ |
Closed-End |
3.99% |
| Claymore MACROshares Oil Up Tradable Trust |
UCR |
U |
ETF |
3.34% |
| Ultra Oil & Gas ProShares |
DIG |
U |
ETF |
3.10% |
| Profunds Oil Equip Dist & Services UltraSector ProFund |
OEPIX |
U |
Open-End |
2.85% |
| Fidelity Select Energy Service Portfolio |
FSESX |
C+ |
Open-End |
2.79% |
| ProFunds Oil & Gas UltraSector ProFund |
ENPIX |
C |
Open-End |
2.40% |
| Rydex S&P Equal Weight Energy ETF |
RYE |
U |
ETF |
2.30% |
| First Trust Energy AlphaDEX Fund |
FXN |
U |
ETF |
2.30% |
| PowerShares Dynamic Oil & Gas Services Portfolio |
PXJ |
B |
ETF |
2.23% |
| Source: Bloomberg |
Read
here for an explanation of our ratings.
10 Worst Performing Energy Funds
Total return for the week ended Aug. 30. |
| Fund |
Ticker |
Rating |
Fund Type |
1 Week Total Return |
| Kayne Anderson Energy Total Return Fund |
KYE |
B |
Closed-End |
-6.53% |
| Claymore MACROshares Oil Down Tradeable Trust |
DCR |
U |
ETF |
-4.86% |
| United States Natural Gas Fund LP |
UNG |
U |
ETF |
-4.25% |
| UltraShort Oil & Gas ProShares |
DUG |
U |
ETF |
-3.73% |
| Kayne Anderson MLP Investment Co |
KYN |
B |
Closed-End |
-2.96% |
| Market Vectors Nuclear Energy ETF |
NLR |
U |
ETF |
-2.24% |
| Kayne Anderson Energy Development Co |
KED |
U |
Closed-End |
-2.01% |
| ProFunds Short Oil & Gas ProFund |
SNPIX |
U |
Open-End |
-1.73% |
| First Trust ISE-Revere Natural Gas Index Fund |
FCG |
U |
ETF |
-1.29% |
| BlackRock Global Resources Fund |
SSGRX |
C- |
Open-End |
-1.28% |
| Source: Bloomberg |
Looking forward, two of the largest drivers of oil prices over the next couple of years may be economic and geopolitical. If the subprime mortgage contagion spreads, it could become difficult for companies to borrow money to purchase new inventory, and that could trigger a wider slowdown in business activity. Demand for energy may shrink with the economic cycle.
On the other hand, the new French President Nicolas Sarkozy does not oppose sanctions against Iran as his predecessor, Jacques Chirac, did. With France joining the U.S. and British mission to prevent Iran from developing nuclear weapons, oil supplies may eventually get squeezed, sending prices higher. If President Bush preemptively lets slip the dogs of war again, this time by attacking Iranian nuclear enrichment sites, the sky's the limit on energy prices.