TheStreet.com RealMoney.com IPOPros.com TheStreetPros.com Your Money/Shopping Help
  Sorry, the page you requested could not be found

Sorry that you couldn't find the page you wanted.

Here are a couple of ways that can help you find that information successfully.

Content Search:

Quote Search:

(Stocks, ETFs, Mutual Funds)

TheStreet Directory

Dow Jones S&P 500 NASDAQ 10-Year Note
10,291.26 1,098.51 2,166.90 34.74
Oil *
77.90
UP
44.29
UP
5.50
UP
15.82
DOWN
0.08
10 Yr
3.47%
SPDR Gold
109.60
+0.43%
+0.50%
+0.74%
-0.23%
Data delayed 20 minutes


Commentary: The New Fundamentals
*New* Alerts! Please click here...

More Warning Flags on Kohl's
By Whitney Tilson
Special to TheStreet.com

1/22/01 9:17 AM ET


I've been enjoying the thought-provoking debate between Arne Alsin and James Cramer on Kohl's (KSS:NYSE - news - boards), and thought I'd weigh in with some numbers that raise real warning flags for me.

Kohl's has been expanding rapidly -- and, I might add, appears to be executing superbly, as same-store sales were up a remarkable 14.8% in December . But I always worry when I see a high-growth company -- especially in the highly competitive, fickle retail industry -- that has negative and declining free cash flow and rapidly rising debt. Here are the numbers that give me pause.

Free Cash Flow

Kohl's free cash flow (defined as operating cash flow, excluding the tax benefit from exercise of stock options, minus net capital expenditures) was only slightly negative for the 12 months ending in the third quarter of 1998, but worsened significantly over the next two years -- despite a rapid rise in net income -- as the following table shows.

The Riskier Financials of Kohl's
Category Trailing 12 months ending Q3 98 Trailing 12 months ending Q3 99 Trailing 12 months ending Q3 00
Net income $170,802 $231,628 $314,230
Operating cash flow* $162,584 $185,377 ($196,577)
Net cap expend. $222,303 $543,296 $495,474
Free cash flow ($59,719) ($357,919) ($692,051)
Source: company reports
* Excluding tax benefit from exercise of stock options

Negative free cash flow is not unusual for a rapidly growing company, especially in the retail sector, because new stores are costly (e.g., capex rises) and inventory levels increase to stock them, which hurts operating cash flow. As long as the new stores thrive and generate high returns on capital, rapid growth -- even at the expense of current free cash flow -- is a good thing for shareholders.

But the negative free cash flow has to be paid for somehow, typically by taking on debt or issuing stock. At modest levels, neither of these things is troubling, but if severely negative free cash flow makes it necessary to issue a great deal of stock, this triggers meaningful dilution for existing shareholders. Or, if the company issues debt, this increases risk should the company encounter difficulties. I can't even begin to count how many retailers have gone out of business by taking on too much debt and then seeing their fortunes decline.

Debt

While Kohl's has raised some capital by issuing stock ($328.5 million over the past three years), its primary method of financing these free cash flow deficits has been via issuing debt. This graph shows Kohl's net debt (total debt minus cash and short-term investments) since the first quarter of 1997.

Over the past six quarters, Kohl's net debt has increased 264%, from $292 million to $1.063 billion. For perspective, that's equal to 3.4 years of Kohl's trailing 12-month net income. Both the magnitude of this debt and its rapid rise are very worrisome.

Conclusion

I think Kohl's is a very well-run company with bright prospects. But there's a big difference between liking the company and liking the stock. At Friday's closing price of $65.94, Kohl's is trading at 50.3 times analysts' consensus estimated earnings for fiscal 2001 (ending next month) of $1.31 a share. That's pricey any way you look at it. With so many undervalued stocks representing solid companies, it doesn't make any sense, to me at least, to buy a stock that is clearly fully valued -- if not significantly overvalued.

I agree with Cramer, however, the Kohl's is a lousy short. As he points out, there's always the chance -- however small -- that Kohl's could turn out to be this decade's version of Wal-Mart (WMT:NYSE - news - boards) in the 1980s or Gap (GPS:NYSE - news - boards) in the early 1990s. In this case, those who are short Kohl's could have their heads handed to them many times over.


Whitney Tilson is Managing Partner of Tilson Capital Partners, LLC, a New York City-based money management firm. At time of publication, Tilson Capital Partners held no positions in any securities mentioned in this column, although holdings can change at any time. Under no circumstances does the information in this column represent a recommendation to buy or sell stocks. Mr. Tilson appreciates your feedback. To read his other writings, click here.
Send letters to the editor to letters@realmoney.com.
Read our conflicts and disclosure policy.
Order reprints of RealMoney.com articles. Top

Research Now
on CSFBdirect
GPS KSS WMT
Open a CSFBdirect account.

RELATED STORIES


The New Fundamentals
Cracking the Books: Manugistics' Mysterious Debt
1/9/01 9:59 AM ET
Why borrow nearly a year's worth of revenue when there's ample cash in the bank? Good question.

The New Fundamentals
Show Me the Money
8/3/00 9:26 AM ET
Studies show Staples isn't worth the price, Robert Half International is.

The New Fundamentals
Seeing Beyond Visx: Part 2
2/25/00 2:36 PM ET
Visx's mystery competitior in the laser eye-surgery device market is revealed!




TECH CENTER
Technology for your business!

Apply now for a csfbdirect account ONLINE INVESTING
Invest with CSFBdirect today.
FINANCIAL PUBLICATIONS
Risk-free issue of Red Herring



Click to change or update chart Click to change or update chart Click to change or update chart

Sorry, the page you requested could not be found

Sorry that you couldn't find the page you wanted.

Here are a couple of ways that can help you find that information successfully.

Content Search:

Quote Search:

(Stocks, ETFs, Mutual Funds)

TheStreet Directory

Dow Jones S&P 500 NASDAQ 10-Year Note
10,291.26 1,098.51 2,166.90 34.74
Oil *
77.90
UP
44.29
UP
5.50
UP
15.82
DOWN
0.08
10 Yr
3.47%
SPDR Gold
109.60
+0.43%
+0.50%
+0.74%
-0.23%
Data delayed 20 minutes