Stephen Schurr

Try Jim Cramer's Action Alerts PLUS
CLICK HERE NOW

How Fear Rules the Fund Flock

12/19/02 - 06:56 AM EST

Stephen Schurr

At T. Rowe Price's annual investment briefing earlier this month, PRGFXGrowth Stock fund manager Robert W. Smith worried aloud about investor short-sightedness, saying, "Individuals must stop renting stocks and start owning stocks again."

Smith said this trader mentality heightened market instability, and his point was well-taken. Then again, so was a question put to Smith by a reporter: "When do you think fund managers will stop renting stocks and start owning them?"

Smith, the subject of a recent 10 Questions, might be the wrong manager to ask -- his fund has topped the market and most of his peers during the past 10 years while keeping expenses, risk and turnover fairly low. But the discussion illustrates a key point: Money managers, far more than often-blamed individual investors and daytraders, deserve the lion's share of the blame for the market volatility of the past several years, because of their "herding" mentality and performance-chasing. And if the past few months are any indication, plenty of money managers are still acting like traders.

Herding

A study in the October Journal of Finance titled "Who Blinks in Volatile Markets: Individuals or Institutions?" concluded that institutions -- mutual funds, in particular -- bear more responsibility for short-term volatility than individuals. The researchers compared stocks that were essentially identical except for institutional ownership levels. On "event days" -- days when the market rose or fell by 2% or more -- stocks with high institutional ownership levels were far more volatile than stocks held largely by individuals. They attribute this to "herding" behavior by fund skippers.

"Institutional managers should be a bit brighter and less subject to biases than individuals," said Patrick J. Dennis, a University of Virginia associate professor and co-author of the study with Deon Strickland of the Securities and Exchange Commission. The study examined stock market volatility over eight years through the end of 1996. Dennis said fund managers are prone to cause more volatility because of a combination of behavioral finance, "asymmetric information" -- in other words, "thinking that the other guy who is buying may have heard something through the grapevine that I haven't" -- and simply the dictates of their job market.

Previous «
1 2 3

Stephen Schurr



05/19/08
Cramer on Top Searched Stocks: Yahoo!

Yahoo! is among the most searched stocks on TheStreet.com. Here's what Cramer had to say about the stock recently.


05/17/08
Jim Cramer's Best Blogs

Catch up on his thinking on the hottest topics of the past week.


04/26/08
Coming Week: Make or Break

Investors will have to deal with a Fed meeting and another flood of earnings and economic data.


05/19/08
Top Rocket Stocks: Ensco

Ensco International and Echelon have the potential to move higher in coming days.


04/28/08
Monday's Analysts' Upgrades, Downgrades

See who made what calls.


05/19/08
Telecom Giants See a Savior in Video

The addition of video is helping telecom companies compete against cable and satellite companies.


05/19/08
Contract Expiration Tempers Oil's Rise

The June West Texas Intermediate contract reflects selling pressure ahead of Tuesday's expiration. But stocks in the sector are generally trading higher.


05/19/08
Analysts' Upgrades, Downgrades: Amazon

See who made what calls.


Your Recent Quotes: Quote Up0 | Quote Down0
Dow S&P 500 NASDAQ
Oil*
Gold
10 Yr
0.00%
%
%
%
Data delayed 20 min
Sign up for our FREE newsletters now.

Keep on top of the market and the critical information you need to make more profitable investing decisions.

  • Cramer's Daily Booyah!
  • Before the Bell

Privacy Policy

See All Free Newsletters

Premium Stock Ideas
Access Action Alerts Plus to find out Cramer’s latest picks now!