This Day On The Street
Continue to site
This account is pending registration confirmation. Please click on the link within the confirmation email previously sent you to complete registration.
Need a new registration confirmation email? Click here

Warning of Better Times Ahead for Shares

Editor's note: This is a bonus column from Jon Markman that appeared earlier today on RealMoney . We're offering it today to readers. To read Jon's premium commentary, please click here for information about a free trial to RealMoney.

As if you really needed more evidence of the perversity of the stock market, analysts at ISI Group in New York have determined that the greater the number of negative preannouncements in the month before the end of a quarter, the better stocks tend to do at the start of the next quarter.

This insight has become especially relevant as the announcements of unexpected earnings shortfalls have been falling like a hard rain on Wall Street in the past two weeks. It's one thing when earnings-challenged basket cases such as telecom chipmaker Broadcom (BRCM) admit they've blown it again. But it's quite another when American icons such as Coca-Cola (KO) and Colgate-Palmolive (CL) come clean with shocking disappointments.

Intuitively, you would guess that a high rate of negative preannouncements would lead to declines in share values over the following month. And you would think that a low rate of negative preannouncements would tend to lead to stronger share values in the subsequent month. But you would be wrong on both counts, according to ISI's eye-opening analysis.

Earnings estimate data in June this year, according to the report, showed that the negative-to-positive preannouncement ratio for stocks in the S&P 500 was less than 1.0. That shouldn't have been considered good news. Instead, says ISI, it was a sign that most positive earnings scenarios for the quarter had been priced into equities -- and that a lousy July was around the corner. And that is what happened, as the S&P 500 sank a whopping 3.4% in the month.

Conversely, then, it may be great news that preannouncements have been so wildly awful this month. According to First Call, the negative/positive preannouncement ratio for the S&P 500 in September so far is 1.9. Analysts' earnings expectations for the coming quarter have thus become gloomy. Indeed, they're the most dreary since the third quarter of 2003. The ratio for tech stocks in the S&P 500 is a touch higher than for the broad market, at 2.0.

So the upshot is that while September may be rough from the standpoint of news, the negativity may be setting the table for improved market performance in October.

Here's a brief glance back at the recent historical record to show how this has played out before:

  • A very high negative-to-positive preannouncement ratio of 2.9 in March 2003 came just ahead of a one-month change in the S&P 500 of 8.1% in April 2003, according to ISI and First Call data.
  • A ratio of 1.7 in September 2003 preceded a 5.5% gain the next month.
  • The highest negative preannouncement ratio of the past five years, 6.8 in March 2001, preceded a 7.7% gain in April 2001.
  • Likewise, a 5.3 ratio in June 1997 preceded a 7.8% July that year.
  • Conversely, a quiescent preannouncement ratio of 1.0 in March 2000 preceded a 3.1% decline in April that year.
  • And a modest 1.0 ratio in June 2002 preceded a 7.9% plunge in July that year.
  • A reasonable interpretation of ISI's study is that the market is highly effective at pricing in (and anticipating) bad news. So, to take this concept a little further, I ran a screen to discover the S&P 500 stocks for which analysts have the lowest expectations over the next year. If the ISI theory is right, high levels of negativity among investment professionals might lead to outperformance for these stocks in the next month as the bogeymen turn out to be not quite so scary as feared.

    S&P 500 Stocks With Negative Analyst Growth Expectations
    Company Name Symbol Next Yr % Est. Growth Current Qtr. % Est. Growth StockScouter Rating Last Price
    Winn-Dixie Stores WIN -320 -700 4 $3.80
    LSI Logic LSI -6.8 -221.4 5 $4.38
    AT&T T -78.7 -87.2 8 $15.49
    Dynegy DYN -2187.5 -48 10 $4.57
    Countrywide Financial CFC -2.7 -44.9 7 $37.30
    Lehman Brothers Holdings LEH -3.6 -14.6 9 $76.02
    Bear Stearns BSC -7 -14.6 8 $87.74
    Bristol-Myers Squibb BMY -12.5 -13.5 6 $24.24
    BellSouth BLS -15.1 -4.7 8 $27.71
    Source: MSN Money

    Of these stocks, it's interesting to note that widely hated Dynegy (DYN), AT&T (T) and Bristol-Myers Squibb (BMY) have all been trading up in the past couple of weeks in opposition to consensus earnings expectations. Dynegy, the utility noted for its decision to back out of a merger with Enron in that benighted company's waning days, in fact appeared to break out of an eight-month trading range on Monday with a 9-cent advance.

    I'll keep track of these stocks, and the fate of the negative preannouncement ratio, as October unfolds.
    At the time of publication, Markman was long Dynegy, although positions may change at any time.

    Jon D. Markman is publisher of StockTactics Advisor , an independent weekly investment research service, as well as senior strategist and portfolio manager at Pinnacle Investment Advisors. He also writes a weekly column for CNBC on MSN Money . While Markman cannot provide personalized investment advice or recommendations, he welcomes column critiques and comments at

    Check Out Our Best Services for Investors

    Action Alerts PLUS

    Portfolio Manager Jim Cramer and Director of Research Jack Mohr reveal their investment tactics while giving advanced notice before every trade.

    Product Features:
    • $2.5+ million portfolio
    • Large-cap and dividend focus
    • Intraday trade alerts from Cramer
    Quant Ratings

    Access the tool that DOMINATES the Russell 2000 and the S&P 500.

    Product Features:
    • Buy, hold, or sell recommendations for over 4,300 stocks
    • Unlimited research reports on your favorite stocks
    • A custom stock screener
    Stocks Under $10

    David Peltier uncovers low dollar stocks with serious upside potential that are flying under Wall Street's radar.

    Product Features:
    • Model portfolio
    • Stocks trading below $10
    • Intraday trade alerts
    14-Days Free
    Only $9.95
    14-Days Free
    Dividend Stock Advisor

    David Peltier identifies the best of breed dividend stocks that will pay a reliable AND significant income stream.

    Product Features:
    • Diversified model portfolio of dividend stocks
    • Updates with exact steps to take - BUY, HOLD, SELL
    Trifecta Stocks

    Every recommendation goes through 3 layers of intense scrutiny—quantitative, fundamental and technical analysis—to maximize profit potential and minimize risk.

    Product Features:
    • Model Portfolio
    • Intra Day Trade alerts
    • Access to Quant Ratings
    Real Money

    More than 30 investing pros with skin in the game give you actionable insight and investment ideas.

    Product Features:
    • Access to Jim Cramer's daily blog
    • Intraday commentary and news
    • Real-time trading forums
    Only $49.95
    14-Days Free
    14-Days Free
    AAPL $93.99 0.00%
    FB $102.01 0.00%
    GOOG $682.40 0.00%
    TSLA $151.04 0.00%
    YHOO $27.04 0.00%


    Chart of I:DJI
    DOW 15,973.84 +313.66 2.00%
    S&P 500 1,864.78 +35.70 1.95%
    NASDAQ 4,337.5120 +70.6750 1.66%

    Free Reports

    Top Rated Stocks Top Rated Funds Top Rated ETFs