Funds Notebook: New Baron Fund Pays for Visibility in Schwab Supermarket
01/18/00 - 04:28 PM EST
Three or four times each year, Charles Schwab (SCH Quote) heavily promotes a new mutual fund to customers and advisers during the fund's subscription period. In return, the fund's adviser pays Schwab an additional fee beyond what it pays to be included in Schwab's OneSource fund supermarket.
In the latest of these agreements, Schwab has agreed to market the Baron iOpportunity fund, which starts raising money today in a six-week subscription period that ends Feb. 29. During this period, investors can reserve shares at $10. After Feb. 29, investors' money will be pooled and used to launch the fund's portfolio. (TSC first reported on these promotional arrangements in a story last fall.) Schwab will advertise iOpportunity on the home page of its Web site, as well as in emails to customers and financial advisers. These promotional efforts, slated to start in a couple of weeks, will give the fund greater visibility than the other funds on OneSource. (The fund wasn't listed on the Web site at midday Tuesday.) Schwab says the agreements aren't a conflict of interest, but they seem to add a tilt to what otherwise appears to be a level playing field among the funds in the OneSource program. "If they have an enhanced interest in any fund and it ends up with additional promotion, that's a conflict of interest," says Frank Armstrong, president of Miami financial planning firm Managed Account Services and chief investment strategist for DirectAdvice.com. Schwab disagrees. "We don't think it's a conflict of interest at all," says spokesman Morrisson Shaffroth. "These [agreements] are opportunities for our clients to get in on the ground floor in interesting funds. There's no sales pressure or incentives to our employees. It's just another example of Schwab being an innovator." Shaffroth says there's a big difference between Schwab giving a fledgling fund higher prominence and traditional brokers' old-school tactic of boosting commissions on a new fund. Last fall, for example, PaineWebber (PWJ Quote) upped the payout on sales of its new Strategy fund, which raised a whopping $2.1 billion during a six-week subscription. (For more on this practice, known as dealer reallowance, see a previous story.) Shaffroth also argues that any extra prominence a fund has on the Schwab Web site should be considered advertising, not an endorsement. He also points out that the agreement is disclosed in fund filings and on Schwab's site. But critics say that expecting investors to discern such a fine line and read small-print disclosures is unrealistic. "If Schwab puts this [fund] on their front page, people will see it as an endorsement or another reason to buy it. How much of the fine print do you really expect someone to read?" asks Joel Davis, a senior financial planner with American Express Financial Advisors in Portland, Maine. Despite these concerns, it's worth pointing out that investors who piled into funds Schwab promoted during subscription periods probably aren't complaining. In the past few years Schwab has promoted Janus (JAGLX Quote)Global Life Sciences, Janus (JAGTX Quote)Global Technology, Stein Roe (SRLFX Quote)Large Company Focus and Invesco (IVENX Quote)Endeavor. Each has trounced its average peer since being launched. And fund companies have had reason to smile, too. Most recently Schwab promoted Hambrecht & Quist's (HQ Quote) IPO and Emerging Company fund, which raised $177 million during a six-week subscription period last fall. Baron (BSCFX Quote)Small Cap raised more than $100 million with Schwab's help in 1997. Baron's new iOpportunity fund will be managed by Matt Ervin and Mitch Rubin, two analysts who joined Ron Baron on the Baron (BGRFX Quote)Growth fund's management about a year ago. The two will select securities from a buy list maintained by Baron and Morty Schaja, the firm's president.



